The US policy of 14 day quarantine for healthcare workers who had even limited exposure to a COVID patient was never sustainable and threatened to shut entire ERs before the restrictions were loosened.
A broad array of moderate measures (stringent hand washing, surgical masks all the time, 6 foot rule except during exams, etc.) combined with isolation of only identified “close” contacts has worked in a few different places now.
The question of asymptomatic spread is still confounding experts. It seems they can’t fully explain the spread in some places without it, but they can’t explain lack of spread in some places with it.
When left in a situation where data is conflicting and unreliable, I think the path forward has to always balance the conflicting interests. Just like you can’t send the entire ER department home in the middle of an epidemic, you also can’t exhaust your entire years supply of hazmat gear in a week, and you similarly can’t crater your entire economy to put on a show of strong action.
Measured responses ultimately are what will save the most lives, because they can be sustained for the reasonable expected duration of the outbreak rather than shock and cripple the whole system in a matter of weeks.