I'm not sure I agree that people are necessarily making poor decisions. "Worse" is a contextual parameter.
I have a 6S+ from 2015 that I am still using and it works fine for me. I'm debating whether to replace the battery or buy a whole new phone in the fall. Camera quality long ago exceeded what I care about so I no longer even consider the camera when considering a phone, though I have friends for whom it's very important. Both of us are correct. Same applies to screen (my main reason for considering an upgrade), cpu etc. They are adequate for my needs.
OTOH I will be buying a close-to-top-of-the-line iPad Pro I can use for demos (just yank it out of my bag and go) that would actually run more slowly on my laptop! Yet the specs of such a machine are absurd for most people.
Does iPhone make my phone calls more phoney?
I am an Android user but I like buying products once and using them until they die. I have a pixel 2 that I got new less than 2 years ago that will be reaching EOL soon, which is really surreal. Buying an iPhone that can last 5+ years sounds like a real benefit -- and would actually save me a lot of money over the long term even though it costs more than 1.5x as much as my pixel. That sounds like a real benefit for me personally, and I may be switching to iPhone next, if only for their excellent history of long term support (I prefer Android's software)
There are risk-resuction benefits to only expecting 2-3 years from your phone. Especially if you are a heavy user of your phone and subject to (cough) battery degradation and CPU throttling.
Pixel 2 is also $150 refurb in excellent condition, so thank you whoever is buying it new.
But most people buy the second or third from the bottom, which in a crowded catalog can be quite awful and need to be replaced prematurely.