Any response that is not federal is going to struggle.
The buck stops solely at the white house and congress for failing to see the warning signs and properly respond.
[0] https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2020/03/burr-unloaded-stock...
If you listen to WH pressers, you will see that federal government wants the governors to do what they can to procure stuff and enact measures for their states, and step in when the governors feel their response will be inadequate. Which is what we're observing in CA and NY as the governors of those states chose to put politics aside for the time being and actually engage.
The reason for delegating frontline response to the states is that if the federal government steps in to buy medical supplies for example (which BTW it still does from time to time - they ordered $500M worth of N95 masks yesterday), such a purchase would first soak up available capacity, and then it'd have to be disbursed to the states, instead of going to them directly, adding delay and confusion.
FWIW, I have not seen this level of coordinated response to _anything_ and I've been in the US for 20 years now. I did not know some of the things that are being done are even possible. FEMA and Army Corps of Engineers started to step in massively over the past week. Companies are starting to make ventilators. Drugs and testing equipment are approved for use in weeks instead of years. The list goes on.
Let's be honest, Cuomo just went out and outbid everyone to get the materials his people needed. He didn't work with the admin to do a thing, he waved money around in the global marketplace. Not hating on him, that's his job. He's supposed to look out for New Yorkers. But a lot of states out there don't have New York's bottomless checkbook. Nor do they have New York's influence.
Easy to look good when you're not really depending on the federal government for testing throughput. Again, guy's done a great job. But he's done it by circumventing the limitations set by the administration not really by living with them like the rest of us have to.
https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/0...
It’s good people are holding them up to a high standard (elections are regularly presented as choosing the lesser of evils) but when all of them seem to be getting killed it makes you wonder if it’s just the nature of the beast. Especially in the west.
The few who have gotten praise (South Korea) were the ones that were more likely to ignore WHO and bypass other typical established political processes, allowing them to react quickly - and are by far the rare exceptions, not the rule.
‘Government’ and ‘moving quickly’ are rarely things you see in the same sentence in normal times, nor would ‘good’ politicians typically be defined as the ones who ignore the recommendations of international organizations, but yet it’s something everyone thinks can immediately be fixed on demand like flipping a switch.
Here is a handy guide:
- If they are angry at the media, they are confused and should be muzzled for a time
- If they are exercising insider trading, they should be removed from office
- If they are coordinating and appear to be going to too much of an extreme regarding lockdown and response, they are actually well informed and should be granted additional responsibility and leadership, if capable
- If they are offering help to business but not individuals, they should be muzzled for the extent of the crisis and not allowed to submit amendments or legislation
- If they are deliberately slowing down responses, they should be muzzled for the extent of the crisis and their decision powers be given to their deputies
- If they are ensuring the public nothing is wrong they are incorrect and should be muzzled for the extend of their crisis, and their decision and executive powers given to their deputies.
These heuristics would ensure incompetence is kept in its place -- away from the lives and livelihoods of individuals, and ideally removed from office during the next election cycle as incompetent politicians have no business executing the will of their constituents during wartime or peacetime.
Apparently, it prevents states from making changes to Medicaid this year, but NY already did.
This should ensure that people get the proper care and definitely won't cause large amounts of spreading outside of New Tork.
But I'm not a political type, so if I'm thinking about this wrong I'm open to being corrected.
I'm disappointed I guess.
I've always had limited faith and political and economic leaders, but this crisis has really just cratered the little faith I did have.
Let's screw the liberal states?
Let's make a few bucks on the stock market?
Just, wow. Can't even be angry really, I don't deserve any better. In a democracy, you get exactly the leaders you are deserving of. I guess I know how much we rate. Lesson learned.
I suppose the poor cannot vote you out if they are dead.
Just, yeah.
To not only do all the stuff that our politicians, of every political stripe, are doing, but then to screw over the poor at a time like this as well?
I think I'm done here for the day. I'm pretty sure I don't want to know anything more about what the politicians are doing.
If you make $75,000 in New York, you're probably homeless... but in the red states that's fuck you money.