Physics laws cannot always turn back time
astronomie.nl
astronomie.nl
General HN comment: I think our discussion on physics topics will really be improved if we comment on the physics papers (start with the abstracts) themselves.
The (completely understandable) trend right now is to focus on the press release or science journalism that accompanies the link to the physics. Unfortunately that normally leads away from the basics of what's actually happening in the physics.
(Metaphor here: If you're a programmer, imagine reading about some CS topic in Wired magazine, then looking at 200 comments from people who agree or disagree with the pop sci writeup.)
But I agree, it would be nice to have the primary source handy, right here on this page.
This is really an argument about the ability to measure and simulate, not about which of the laws of physics are invariant under time reversal.
What they do is to increase the accuracy so much that physical perturbations at the quantum level dominate, not numerical accuracy. Irreversible up to the Planck length means fundamentally unpredictable.
Yeah, that's the point right there up front: Butterfly effect at the sub-Planck scale.
In some other thread, people told me I was wrong about reality having finite resolution. So is there a "sub-Planck scale"? How can simulations tell you if there is or isn't?
Chaos theory is math. This is physics showing how the math applies to reality.
(I'm not talking about statistical sources such as large particle collectives.)
My understanding is that measuring quantities smaller than the Planck limits is problematic. (IIRC, the energy of a photon needed to make the measurement is large enough to create a black hole.) As a result, it's not just "numerics"; the theory may be symmetric, but the physical system cannot be observed to be.
Does the above mean the exact same thing as saying that the laws of physics are not time invariant period?
If you attempt to observe anything at that scale, you will create a black hole. Without a theory of quantum gravity, it's sort of nonsensical to talk about what happens at that scale of space-time.
If I recall from Brief History of Time, it's the combination of charge, parity, and time all together which are invariant. Some google searching also yields that time crystals were shown to disprove time symmetry/invariance.
(Side note: significant digits were a royal PITA)
If the process being measured is dependent on changes of sub-Planck length magnitude, you have an inherently chaotic system, and that makes it irreversible in practice.
There are open questions: Why would their accuracy be sufficient? Is there a proof of it being sufficient to make such a claim? Then we have: Is their simulation correct? Can we even make a correct simulation inside a computer, about 3 black holes and in addition to that, make general statements about laws of physics, based on the results of that simulation? Perhaps to make a perfect simulation, to be really sure, we would need an apparatus of as much matter as fell into those black holes.
So I remain sceptical.
Autonitpicking: There are some technical details about time reversal, but as far as we know the CPT symmetry is not broken.
Based purely on the fact that events happen randomly within some constraint then if you go forward, backward or repeat nothing can ever be the same even when initial conditions are exactly identical?
Nobody is sure, but probably when you consider a bigger system that includes the experiment and the observer, the time reversion is restored. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_decoherence
(Note that the observer in QM doesn't need magical properties like consciousness, in some experiments it is enough to place a brick in the right position.)
Everything we know so far points to time invariance * , right? What would happen if we discovered that some things truly aren't time invariant? Would it crucially change the fundamental understanding, or would it just be a new class of phenomena?
* except maybe TFA which isn't really right based on the other comments I'm reading.
Time symmetry is typically synonymous with energy conservation in classical mechanics. It get's more complicated when you introduce quantum mechanics, and lorentz invariance from relativity. In essence though, there's probably an analogous invariant to energy conservation for CPT symmetry. Maybe this is just lorentz invariance for a quantum field theroy? Not quite sure.
Implications of seeing that symmetry broken would be huge since the CPT theorem implies that a quantum field theory obeying lorentz invariance obeys a CPT symmetry. (I'm guessing by an application of Noether's theorem?) SO a violation of that would be either a violation of lorentz invariance (which would be VERY interesting) or some type of violation of the assumptions of quantum field theory. In essence, it would mean new physics!
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modern_searches_for_Lorentz_vi...
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Singular_Universe_and_th...
Nothing to see here about time reversal, its just chaos.
The blurb that's linked to HN is not very lucid, but the scientists who wrote the paper make it very clear that they're just talking about deterministic chaos.
Newsflash: a simple double pendulum also requires Planck length precision in initial conditions (or would if it weren't for, like, friction) for reversibility if you sit around and watch it for long enough and excite it properly.
But apparently that's actually a lot of what it's about, in which case the authors are well aware - but it's still not very interesting then. The Lorenz attractor is is simpler than a 3-body system and will exhibit similar divergence.
Time Travel Is Possible, But We’ll Need Lots Of Negative Energy
The article is pointing at a more subtle issue related to a fundamental small-scale fuzziness which affects chaotic systems and breaks reversibility.
But look, you go to school and they drill into you until the cows come home that quantum mechanics is time-reversible, and gravity is time-reversible, and you just assume this is always true.
But turns out, all that's needed is a bit of small-scale fuzziness due to QM effects, and then particle ensembles of 3 or more are suddenly not time-reversible anymore, though each of the basic laws still are.
For someone like me this was a small shock.
Often understanding something better makes it less obvious, but at my level, I don't understand what's non-obvious about this.