So you think that he should spend 1.5 years in a Russian prison for that? A sentence that may very well ruin him psychologically for the rest of his life? And/or leave him with TB and/or Covid-19? (and here I note that American prisons are not much better, if at all).
hold on... no one ever said anything like that. not a single comment here. let's keep calm.
the whole situation still seems unreal to myself...
if you read below, someone who can actually read the court documents said the victim was not lying around, but actually helping the other person.
just too much unknown to form our own personal judgement here. that's all i was trying to say.
A good portion of my reasoning comes from my daily dealings with my kids. This case bears many strong resemblances to arguments they come to me with.
Edit to clarify: when my kids come to me with an argument because one was careless and hurt another, the defense is usually that they were acting as reasonably cautious as could be expected. My justification in grounding them (after getting the facts and eyewitness testimony) is that I would have acted more cautiously than they did given the circumstances, and would not have caused the same injury, so that their caution wasn’t really as cautious as should reasonably be expected.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/41023722-the-million-dol...
I think both the US and Russia should dramatically rethink their approach to non violent crime. Both countries have ridiculously high incarceration rates.
I may be wrong, but I believe most people on HN feel the same way.
Also, to be clear, are you sympathetic to the incarceration of drug dealers and thieves but not sympathetic to the incarceration of someone who accidentally killed someone in an auto-pedestrian accident?
Didn't see this because you added it in an edit. I think we should generally avoid prison time as much as possible, for all of these cases.
I just get frustrated when I often seem to see people defending people with similar social status to themselves, but having apparently no sympathy for people of different social circumstances.
Clearly the consensus on HN is not entirely the same way, as some of the other replies to my comment show.
I am sorry for having assumed intentions that you don't have, though, more trying to comment on a general trend I've observed.
Circumstances as described possibly mitigating some aspects of this, but driving (or motorcycle riding) is an inherently and widely known dangerous activity. Situational awareness is a requisite practice.
But yes: a proper respect for circimstances and situation might have avoided the accident.
The only way you do not notice incoming shit at this speed riding a bike is because the shit literally jumps at you.
I know only too well what the "courts of law" are like in Russia. My opinion is that the guy got a wrong lawyer who either could not pass a bribe to the judge, or the other side passed a bigger bribe.
It is simply the case that things happen out of a driver's control. In the US you'd be looking at a consideration for involuntary manslaughter charge (or perhaps a lesser negligence charge) if it was found that they were speeding or impaired. Absent those circumstances, it's unlikely any charge would be brought forth. There are some other ways a similar charge could be brought in an investigation, but that's generally how it goes.
A final note on the topic of getting drunk and playing in traffic. I highly recommend you get people that do stuff like this to sign up for organ donation. I have a good friend who had a congenital heart defect that benefited from a heart transplant. This was after the donor walked into traffic blitzed on holiday. So it might be that out of the tragedy of a wasted life they might be able to save someone else's.
The correct take is jail time for non-violent crime and no jail time for programmers who (regardless of whether we believe his story) killed someone?
And I'm not. The Russian justice system convicts 99.75% of those accused. The police work may or may not have been reasonable, but the judgment is a rubber stamp.