We are not doomed to always be irrational. We can create knowledge and, with effort, remove errors from it. Then, when we have supporting knowledge, we can act reasonably rationally.
We are not doomed to always be irrational. We can create knowledge and, with effort, remove errors from it. Then, when we have supporting knowledge, we can act reasonably rationally.
There are plenty important scientific discoveries accepted only after the generation change. Bayesian statistics is one example of such process happening right now. Instead of being accepted or rejected based on the merits, the process of acceptance is being dragged along with all sorts of totally human irrationalities.
BTW Bayesian statistics as a replacement for science is not being accepted because it's no good. It's no good because it does not deal in explanations.
And explanations that people care about are just that what the link is all about - rationalization. Or in other words just because there is no good "explanation" for QM doesn't mean it shouldn't be accepted.
As for raw QM, it corresponds to reality, but people are right to also want to know what it means. And we do know. MWI is a good explanation of QM. There's no need to be an instrumentalist, and being one is not a way of overcoming bias. Explanations of what bias is, and how to overcome it, are one of our major tools against it. (See, again, The Fabric of Reality on MWI (chapter 2), instrumentalism (chapter 1), and about explanations in chapters 1,3,4,7 and mixed in throughout.)
The book QED by Feynman also contains very good explanations about QM, but without mention of MWI, so you can see that even with no particular interpretation of QM there is a lot of scope for explanation.
The cold rationality lies in the math you have to study for 2-3 years to learn how to add up these little amplitude arrows. Using that you can actually model and make predictions.
Another great example is Maxwell, he got all the rationalizations "wrong" but the math survived and is called after him.
Here's the kind of arguments I would find rational - http://www.amazon.com/Probability-Causality-AI/lm/R2GX832Q1M...