Unpaid leave puts people in the position of having to decide between health (and not infecting their coworkers) and losing money. Paid sick leave instead puts employees in the position of being able to look after themselves (and their coworkers) without penalties.
It might seem like a trivial difference for people who make decent money, but it's a huge difference for people who are not in a good financial situation.
> get a doctor's note to prove you are sick
Only if you work for a company that doesn't trust its employees.
I've only worked in countries with paid sick leave, and I honestly don't remember if I ever had to present a doctor's note.
if your pay was low, and you get sick leave, then management is going to count the sick leave as part of your pay (even tho you don't necessarily use it up). This then incentivises the worker to "use up" sick leave even if they aren't sick.
Higher pay + unlimited sick leave (unpaid) means that the pay is upfront. The total amount paid being the same would mean that the worker doesn't have to fake a sickie every now and then to get their fair share of their wages. Managers also would not see any sick leave as the worker taking advantage.
It doesn't have to be that way.
Every job I've ever had it's just a matter of emailing or calling my boss to say I won't be in, and that's that.
No Doctor. No authorization. No hassle. Unlimited days. Sick people shouldn't be at at work, and any job worth a damn trusts it's employees to do the right thing.
Jobs in Canada and Australia.
Sick leave = "stay home if sick, still get same money"
"higher pay + unpaid leave" = "stay home if sick, get less money"
An employer has x amount of dollars allotted for an employee. This x includes everything that the employer needs to employ you: your salary, your vacation time (and pay), you tools etc. If you require that employers provide sick leave then x is still going to stay the same. That sick leave will simply come from some other pool, such as the salary or the money allotted for training or tools.
Contractors get "higher pay + unpaid leave"
But in fact, it's misleading to call them "contractors". Back in the day, they would have been called "temps".
The importance of sick leave isn't the gross expected balance of pay and work -- as the grandparent points out, for some values those things will be equal, and employees won't prefer one or the other. (Or, better yet, employees might prefer the higher wages because there's more optionality to it -- they get paid more if they're healthy, and they get paid the same if they're unhealthy.)
That misses the point, though. The real importance of sick-leave is about marginal incentives. If an employee is sick, they don't need to weigh one more day of pay against the risk of infecting their coworkers -- they have no incentive to come into the office.