They take the quite extreme point of view that all intellectual property should be completely abolished. They make IMO a definitive point on the complete uselessness of patents in general; the case against copyright and trademarks is somewhat less clear.
Sure, I skimmed it a bit, but don't have time to read it at the moment.
As for the summary of their points, thanks for posting them - I think there's ample room for debate, and that each thing is probably a bit different - software patents are different from drug patents, for instance.
For copyright, the case is quite clear too, though it may still be possible that a short copyright (14 years, for instance) may still be better than nothing at all.
Trade secrecy are treated page 188. Basically, it is much more used than patents, so suppressing patents won't change things much. Revealing secrets through patents is very inefficient anyway.
Maybe you should redefine your "normal" level of production? There are two, valid, competing concerns here, that of the content producer and that of society. After all, the point of copyright, according to the US constitution is to "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts". Allowing content producers to make money is merely a means to that end, not an end onto itself.
Not really. I don't think it overlaps enough to cause much of a problem. They don't have the ease of use that downloading stuff does.
> Maybe you should redefine your "normal" level of production?
Without any IP laws, you could, in a thought-experiment world, spend millions of dollars to create a movie, release it, and not make one dime back on it. That would be the last such movie produced. That's "underproduction".
> Allowing content producers to make money is merely a means to that end, not an end onto itself.
Oh, I agree completely with that. Historically, it's been a pretty good means to that end as well. Lately, many cracks are appearing in the foundations, but I have yet to read of a convincing replacement for it. I think things like MacOS, Hollywood movies (well, some of them), and books by professional authors are a good thing for the world, and am not sure that amateurs will replace them.
> Without any IP laws, you could, in a thought-experiment
> world, spend millions of dollars to create a movie,
> release it, and not make one dime back on it. That would
> be the last such movie produced. That's "underproduction".
This is technically true, but IP laws don't provide any guarantee to the contrary. They are irrelevant to that thought experiment. Copyright does not guarantee profit.There's a decent argument to be made that this would happen more often without IP laws, but then you're moving away from the thought-experiment world. Doing that makes it not clear-cut.
Of course copyright does not 'guarantee' profit: you can make a shitty movie and lose money. However it provides some protection for content producers and indicates a fairly clear path to making money: make something and sell it.
A digital example where there is a balance would be iOS, you don't see big antipiracy efforts from developers because there is plenty of market happy to pay for goods.
The real issue is when a content producer can't make anything at all on their time/ money investment, libraries on the whole have never caused this the way digital downloads may.
Point 2, please review http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2112207
The real issue is whether we see them as "content producers" or artists, or maybe a bit of the two.
I use the words artists and content producers interchangeably, I guess thinking in terms of the word artist makes their work sound more unique and valuable than content producer.
But how to channel taxes to produce the information goods people want? My proposal is to set up a series of "Content Compensation Funds" and taxpayers get to choose which fund their taxes go to -- http://cabalamat.wordpress.com/2009/01/27/a-broadband-tax-fo...
Woah, that's just one way of ensuring that they are produced: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good#Possible_solutions
I am no free-market fundamentalist, but I think the idea of the government sticking its nose into the production of books, movies, music and software to that degree is not entirely to my liking. It also has a number of practical issues: someone could happily snarf down zillion-dollar blockbuster movies, yet dedicate all their taxes to some indie musician they like. At least it has some semblance of a market to it, rather than simply having the Minister of Information Goods who decides who gets what, but I'm not convinced it's as good as a "real" market.
My best guess is that reconfiguring the current compromise in favor of consumers, rather than some producers (copyright extensions, etc...) might be the best course of action, but I am not convinced 100% of anything.
I copied the "quotes" on real because it applies to both solutions, in both cases you're creating some kind of market with the hope that it functions better than no market at all, or any alternative market.
The problem (or at least part of it) is that people, even those that have thought about it for a while, are too quick to accept the current IP mess as natural, unchangeable, morally correct and real, when it is none of those things.
I'm not saying public subsidies should be off the table, just that this proposal and others I've seen don't seem to be as good as reforming the current system.
Dentist needs billing software. He's going to pay through the nose and face a free rider problem if he just pays some guy straight up to write it and release it under a liberal open source license. The software may not get written at all!
If, OTOH, the developer says he'll take a tenth of what it costs him to write it, and the dentist introduces him to 20 of his friends, the dentists all pay less than the labor costs, and the developer makes more money. And the software gets written.
Sure, simplified a lot, and ignoring various options, but you get the idea.
Granted, it takes a lot more than that to be in business, but the IP laws give you some protection against things like that.
If a person thinks the level of production of zillion-dollar movies is OK, but that there should be more indie musicians, that would be a sensible thing for them to do. If lots of people think like that, then the sorts of information goods they like will become better-funded, and information goods that few people like will become less well funded, which is surely a feature rather than a bug.
The purpose of an economy is to make things people want; I believe my solution achieves that. Of course, I don't think it's the only way information goods will be funded, or necessarily even the largest one. I think the Coasian solution -- where people group together to commission a work -- is attractive, and will become increasingly important as the internet reduces transaction costs.
* Software
* Pharmaceuticals
* Books
* Music
* Movies
Now, I'm not saying that we'd arrive at that extreme, but you get the idea, no? That's "underproduction" in my mind - it'd be a poorer world with drastically smaller quantities of those things.
For example, at some time you feel a desire to watch some hard sci-fi present-to-past accidental time travel causing an alternate war history movie¹, but don't know any, except for those you've already watched. And you fire off a new tab and start lurking around.
Not exactly kids on the steets begging for MP3s, but someone spending considerate amount on time begging^W searching for something they want, but don't know.
___
1) Hopefully, that — while still being somehow generic — would be a quite narrow definition where not too many movies would fit.