Although, I do get the rationale for wanting a free pass. Cynically speaking... An authentic Yale diploma must be worth a lot.
Limited seats and the Dunning-Krueger effect [1].
I've seen plenty of 18 year olds in graduate classes, and I've seen highly talented students simply read the books for the prerequisite math classes and do quite well.
One of the downsides is that from the teacher's perspective, we are not allowed to know who is electing to take this option. So if 90% of our class is taking pass fail and aiming for a C, we still have to grade as usual and wonder: are these kids just not trying or are they not getting the material.
They'll be forced to relearn the material or continuously fail.
If someone did get an auto pass...do they know the material any more or less?
What percentage would have failed anyway and will struggle in the next class because they should have failed?
Not to mention, any decent hiring manager that knows of this event, if it does occur, would be more suspect of any graduate of Yale (if they attended during the academic period in question) versus an equivalent Ivy.
As the article mentioned, campus is the great equalizer for students of different backgrounds, so give each student a check for the full retail cost of a semester’s tuition and expenses, paid from the school’s endowment, and remove the class from their transcript.
[update] edited for clarity
Would they?
Because this one thing might have happened one semester they would decide that individual is less qualified?
You think there will be alot of folks to choose from?
I would rather hire the person that graduated from Yale a few years ago versus the one hopefully graduating next year, even for a fully remote position.