That's a Git bug.
That's a Git bug.
They choose not to use it, for some reason (since they know about it, from their comment).
But sure, I'll grant you that it has issues. Heck, Git is distributed, so if you're off-network, committing a bunch of code, and your computer breaks, it doesn't matter if you're using stash or commit. It all depends upon your use case.
You're not OP, but if they, needing to switch to a different branch for a bit, "would much rather make a temporary commit to later rebase instead of using git stash" I'm curious why. I know I used to do it because I didn't understand how stash worked, and then I read up on it, noted what the commands are in my listing (since I don't need to use it daily), and refresh my memory from my notes when I need to use it.
But I also prefer to do smaller commits, more often, and find history to be important. Likely because I do a lot of brownfield development and maintenance. And if I need to switch to another branch to help a colleague, and my code is such that I can't commit it yet, I'll either git clone to a new directory (if they're a new employee or someone just learning a project, and I know I'm going to be helping them a lot) or leverage git stash.