Techmeme simply surfaces the hottest content from tech blogs that's getting linked/tweeted right now. It is descriptive, not editorial. If you notice that only 16% of women are being shown covering a story, then your takeaway should be "gosh, only 16% of women wrote interesting posts that are getting linked to on the web" rather than "gosh, techmeme is descriminating against women."
Techmeme just calls it like it sees it. It's awesome in that way.
If you agree, then yeah, Techmeme's awesome.
If you don't agree, then you need to be conscious that Techmeme's presenting you a skewed view of the world. Unless you're actively working to balance it with sources skewed in the other direction then it's going to mean that your overall information sources aren't giving you an accurate picture of reality.
I don't know why Gabe blocks out female voices but from the Atlantic article linked to in my thread he doesn't seem to read any women regularly so my guess is that he either (a) doesn't know he's doing it or (b) doesn't care.
If that's all explained in your article, then I'll just read it later :)
_____
The coverage of the Arrington kerfuffle provides some great examples of a form of structural bias against women that most people overlook. At this point about 65% of the posts I’ve linked to above are by women (31/47, I think). Here’s TechMeme’s summary of the debate:
five guys and Shira
16.6% women.
In a comment on Gender, race, age and power in online discussions, chapter n back in 2008, I talked about representation issues on Techmeme:
the majority of these blogs are generally what Susan C. Herring et. al. refer to in Women and children last: the discursive construction of Weblogs as “filter blogs”, commenting on external events, as opposed to “personal journals” or “knowledge blogs”; TechMeme’s technology is a natural for filter blogs, so it’s unsurprising that this leads to underrepresentation of women and youth.
It’s nice to have such a clear example!At the risk of being pedantic,there are a couple of important lessons here:
- The “neutral” algorithms of sites like Techmeme, memeorandum, and mediagazer are in practice heavily biased against women, and so present yet another challenge for women in general — and women in technology, politics, and media in particular
- If you’re getting a large chunk of your news via Techmeme, you’re getting a very male view of reality
Yes, later in that thread there's data from Google and Bing -- both in the 45-50% range.
EDIT: Also, here's the link to the Susan Herring et. al. paper I mentioned "Women and Children Last: The Discursive Construction of Weblogs" http://blog.lib.umn.edu/blogosphere/women_and_children.html
There were 47 stories. 31 (65%) were by women.
TechMeme highlighted 6. 1 was by women, 16%.
Google's front page had 4/9 women. (44%) Bing's front page had 5/10. (50%)
The biasing in this case seems almost an epiphenomenon; TC tries to focus on certain views of certain subjects and succeeds; whether those views are disproportionately written by men has little to do with anything.
But saying this is a gender problem is like saying that because doctors are more likely male than nurses are, and get paid more than nurses, we should have fewer doctors and more nurses.
I don't know the data on Britannica authors. If there are more guys then women, then there's gender bias, and Classic Stance may or may not be a contributor. But in any case, I don't see what that has to do with Techmeme situation. Ditto with whether or not there's gender bias in the medical profession.
TechMeme’s technology is a natural for filter blogs, so it’s unsurprising that this leads to underrepresentation of women and youth.
This quote makes it sound like women and children write more personal and knowledge stuff, which TechMeme naturally overlooks. Further, it straight up says that this tendency is "unsurprising".
So we are wondering what this has to do with gender bias or why it's surprising that a technology would miss things that it is designed to miss.
But you said he was not reading the summary correctly, so obviously something is not clear here.
Just a thought.