Even before this subprime auto loans were a bubble starting to burst: https://wolfstreet.com/2020/02/11/subprime-auto-loans-explod...
I don't care what they're charging me for the financing. I just care about the final bottom-line price. They can make 50% or 0% on financing for all I care.
Ignore how they say they're arriving at their final number - just look at what the final number is.
If a bank would charge you 4%, then on a 5-year loan for a $30K car, 0% financing is worth on the order of $3,000.
I'd regard the interest rate as fictitious on its own, but it goes into your calculation to determine how good your deal is for comparison.
It doesn’t make any sense to think about it like this - the finance isn’t available without the car and if you want the car without the finance you will suddenly find the price of the car can be lower. They aren’t two separate things. It’s one price!
Even though the provided interest rate, the price of the car, and the trade-in value (if any) are fictitious numbers, they still go into your bottom line cost.
I could be paying 20% finance and be getting a better deal than you paying 0% finance.
Then you are making bad decisions by not considering the time value of money. And I think it's obvious that that's the case and then you can adjust your position to take that into account.
Consider. I have a car that I will sell to you for $100,000. Alternatively, I will offer you a financing arrangement where you get the car today and in 10 years you pay me $105,000.
Now, in this scenario, two things are immediately obvious. First, I'm really dumb for making this offer. I have little to gain and it's a super risky loan for me and it gets really bad over time. Second, you'd be dumb to accept the pay now option over the financing, despite the fact that the final bottom-line price is higher for financing. Even a ridiculously conservative, barely over inflation, adjustment of 4% per year gives you an extra ~$43,000 at the end of that 10 years by taking the financing.
> gives you an extra ~$43,000
So that's counted in your bottom-line price, isn't it?
All that matters is the price at the end, not how it was arrived at.
The finance price on its own gives no information.
Paying $1000 today is not the same as paying $1000 in six month's time - that's the time value of money that people have mentioned.
If you just add up total amounts without factoring in differences between how payments are distributed over time, your comparison can be incorrect, since the larger number in that case isn't necessarily the more expensive one.
To do a proper comparison, you need to calculate the net present value (NPV) or a similar measure that takes into account time value. See e.g. https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/knowledge/va...
Also, lots of comments in this thread not understanding the cost of the vehicle versus the cost of financing. You should always negotiate the cost of the vehicle separately (as low as possible, obviously, between different dealerships), before the financing to prevent being sold on a monthly payment versus total vehicle price. Otherwise, it becomes trivial for the dealership to inflate their margins on your transaction.
[1] https://www.khanacademy.org/economics-finance-domain/core-fi... (Khan Academy: Time value of money)
Which is essentially zero (or less than zero) return adjusted for risk and and discounted for inflation. All of which is especially hard to gauge at the moment. Maybe I'd take a 0% loan for something I'd otherwise put cash on the barrel for at the moment. But it wouldn't be for the purpose of putting the cash into an equities bet.
Remember the adage: If you aren't paying, you are the product.
84 months is also ridiculous for a car loan. That means you will very quickly owe more than the car is worth, a dangerous situation for a lender. They would only offer such a loan if they had alternative contingency plans such as massive penalties.
This is not to negate your point about "buy here pay here" subprime dealers/lenders, which are also part of the problem. But that is a distinctly separate arrangement to what's going on here with new car financing sponsored by the manufacturer.
TLDR Automakers pay to subsidize zero percent financing on new car sales to get the cars out of inventory during periods of weak sales volume.
Well duh that happens the second you drove the car off the lot. On day two of your ownership you still owe the full cost of a brand new car but can only sell someone a second hand car.
That’s just a truism of buying a new car. The length of the finance agreement is irrelevant.
You always want the cheapest money for the longest term. The only reason to go with a shorter term is if the interest rate is significantly lower. Being "underwater" has nothing to do with it.
Only recently have we started financing cars the way we financed houses in the 2000s, and mobile homes in the 1990s etc etc.
I see 0% financing as just an accounting trick to discount a car a few thousand $ without setting expectations for discounts or giving away the money up front.
There may be exceptions, but I've never had or been offered a car loan that had early repayment penalties, so as many other people have said in conversations like these, might as well go for the longest term that gets the lowest rate and pay it off whenever you feel like.
That is a great textbook approach, pick a car you can afford and demand the best deal, but things work differently at car dealerships. These very long loans are not about getting someone a better deal on a selected car. It is more often about taking a monthly payment that the customer can afford, then maximizing the amount of car that payment can finance. At the really shady end it is about getting someone into ANY car.
These 0% deals are the lending arms of the manufactures performing some financial wizardry to keep the metal moving, so to speak. These companies abso-fucking-lutely do not want a bunch of new buyers defaulting on their loans and flooding the market with cheap, lightly used cars.
This for two reasons. The first is obvious, a 1 year old used car is absolutely competition for a new car. The second is much more subtle, a glut of comparable used cars suppress prices below lease residuals. That second fact is critical because, depending on market, leases can make up to 70% of new car sales. The losses from leases can pile up quickly. Imagine selling 80,000 cars on lease and have the fair market value come in just $2,000 less than expected, that's a $160,000,000 loss in a single year. It's a lagging loss too, so you made the money from the sale when times were good, and now you have to pay the penalty for the mistake in three years when times are lean.
It's a balancing act for sure. They want to keep the cheap money flowing to get people in cars, but they know going too far over that line is a kiss of death. Mitsubishi crossed that line during the last recession and couldn't recover. Also, these lending arms act as a solid asset that can be disposed of when times get tough, so it's a good idea to keep them financially healthy.
This is not that. The person above you is referring to manufacturer financing deals. You're buying the financing and the car at the same time from the same parent company. You are paying. The part you pay for is the car. The financing is simply a loss leader.
> They would only offer such a loan if they had alternative contingency plans such as massive penalties.
Penalties aren't a good plan for recovering anything from a person who has defaulted. Nobody is paying the penalties on a car that was already repossessed.
Financiers who are worried about about the default risk on a loan typically do this by requiring down payments up front.