What happens after the 99-year ground lease is up? Are the house and land then sold together on the open market?
What happens after the 99-year ground lease is up? Are the house and land then sold together on the open market?
More people, means more innovations. Higher density leads to a more rapid spread of new ideas and best practices. Workers, entrepreneurs and investors can rapidly reconfigure to seize opportunities. Less density means you're more likely to fall into stagnation, as the one local employer in commute distance slowly circles the drains.
City life comes with significantly better living standards. What you lose in yard space you make up with much higher salaries, better healthcare and education, and more varied cultural options. To a large extent country living is only idyllic because of the technological exports made by high productivity city-dwellers.
I agree that there's a deep human need to connect with nature. But the solution isn't to try to give every man is his own personal Nottingham forest on his property. It's to build high-quality parks and nature reserves, and good transit so people can easily access these amenities.
I'm not entirely sure that the dichotomy of high productivity city-dwellers/lower productivity country dwellers is true any longer though. I'm a dev manager/programmer working remotely, many of my neighbors are also in IT or construction and either work remotely or commute, and many programmers in our company also live in "fly-over" states in rural areas. Most also own chickens, have small farms, or raise competition animals.
But I still understand and see your point, and I see the value in this for suburban areas. I suppose my mind went to areas more rural than the article is talking about.
Overcrowding, traffic jams, very high housing prices, high prices for food and everything else. Yes, you earn more, but you pay more for living in smaller apartments, so the standard of live isn't guaranteed to be improved.
Here's a comparison from Numbeo: You would need around 3,630.58$ in Austin, TX to maintain the same standard of life that you can have with 8,100.00$ in New York, NY. https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?cou...
I think that moderation is best, and there probably are ranges of population density which are the best. Urban sprawl is bad, as is overcrowding in the city center.
In some parts of the world, you can live in a rural area and travel to work by fast trains, so you can have your cake and eat it, too.
As a counterfactual to the NIMBY West, Tokyo has very high density but surprisingly affordable housing because it places few restrictions on building and land use.
The point is that whoever values the land most should get it. If you're willing to pay more taxes on the land than someone who wants to build housing, then you can keep it. If not, the land should go to whoever can make the most productive use of it.
This is how we lose natural land to sprawl. A large chunk is bought by a developer, clear cut, split into many small chunks, and sold to private individuals.
This splitting of the land into many new owners makes conservation of an area in the future to be much harder.
LVT makes sense for urban areas, but should stop where the city line is.
From there out I could see LVT leeding to increasing deforestation, sprawl, and destruction of the natural environment.
In certain areas I would even argue doing the opposite of LVT and be giving people tax incentives to leave land undeveloped and natural, better yet join parcels of adjoining land together in conservation projects while still allowing people to live on it, just where they cannot develop most of it, maybe even allow public access in the form of hiking trails using the "Freedom to Roam" principle.
This is Land front-running - somebody has information you want or will want something and buys it for himself and later reselling to you more expensively (eg. concert ticket scalpers, high frequency trading or simply knowong that there will be generations of youngsters moving to cities so why not to buy real estate there and sell it to them later).
While this market-making can be a useful service for smoothing out price of goods with price fluctuating up and down, it however becomes immoral for badly auctioned goods - such as desirable concert tickets which are often sold to scalpers in large quantities who front-run every other buyer. Also in real estate and land markets - where all the QE printed money creates asset price inflation, so by buying in those markets you can front run people who don't yet have money for it or are not even born yet.
This ceases to be a problem under LVT because you auction land usage fairly to a large degree.
No front-running -> no sitting idle on land by developers and deforestation -> optimal allocation to users.
That's nice, but many people would just like to have a roof over their head that will stay over their head.
Edit: they're specifically requiring someone to build a house there. It seems like if someone wanted to build multifamily housing, even if that would be a better use of the land, they would be turned down. That's a perverse incentive.
You call it a handout, I call it compassionate government.
That would actually reduce market prices instead of requiring a subsidy.
>Compassionate government
Nope, a government driving up market prices by restricting new construction is not compassionate just because they tried to help a handful of families buy below market.
You're free to your opinion this is "inefficient" and causes "perverse incentives". In the meantime, people get homes they otherwise wouldn't. Some of us consider that a win.
The market failure is the government permitting people to buy and sell land. A small trust buying up some land and taking it off the market doesn't fix the underlying failure.
> The market failure is the government permitting people to buy and sell land. A small trust buying up some land and taking it off the market doesn't fix the underlying failure.
This argument is hopeless. Good chat.
Then use the profit this produces over the current system to directly subsidise low income households.
This is more efficient and has the same subsidy effect.
Land shouldn't be sold, it should all be owned by the state and leased out at market value; equivalently, implement LVT at close to 100% of land value.
The state setting a maximum sale price and subsidizing demand is not that.
That there already is a land value tax.
There are plenty of historical examples where people weren't permitted to buy and sell land. It never worked out very well.
Georgism has a solid theoretical foundation.
The result is blight. It often happens with "the projects" where the government builds housing and rents it out.
Renters can have exactly as much community spirit and take as much pride in their dwellings as anyone, but it requires that they're treated with a modicum of respect, which unfortunately is exceedingly rare in lardlordism.
No, they don't. Talk to hotel staff sometime about how their guests treat the rooms, for just one example. Or how people rent cars and go race them. Or how sensible people avoid buying former car rentals.
Anybody in any form of rental business knows it isn't true.
There is a vast difference between a hotel guest or AirBnB renter, who will only be staying a few days or a couple of weeks at most, and someone who rents an apartment/house for years and is part of the local community.
There are also cultural and personal differences, because neither I nor any of my friends would ever trash a short-term rental, whether it was an apartment, hotel room or a car.
However I also know people who don't even give a damn about their own things, they trash everything they touch, it is absolutely not some universal trait in renters.
Overall, the less egotistical a culture is, the better short-term renting, tool sharing and similar programs work.
> neither I nor any of my friends would ever trash a short-term rental, whether it was an apartment, hotel room or a car.
It's not just "trashing". It's in general being harder on things.
I'll give another example, this from the military, as told to me by my father, career Air Force. The military issued combat boots to soldiers, and when they'd wear out, the soldier would present the worn out boot at the supply office, and get a new pair.
They had a rate of boot exchanges that seemed high. As an experiment, the military instead provided the soldiers with a uniform allowance. What they didn't spend they could keep. The boot consumption dropped by a factor of three.
This was not soldiers "trashing" the boots. It was simply not caring about them.
I will treat a rented or borrowed item better than one I own myself, as would my friends, simply because it is the right thing to do and because we would all hate to be handed a mistreated item the next time we rent something.
What you're describing is a cultural issue of people lacking respect for other people, and it is by no means a universal trait in humanity. However a lack of respect usually correlates with immaturity, which is shown in your example from the military. Young men tend to lack the requisite level of maturity.
When people mature, they usually start respecting other people and start caring about making things last for as long as possible. If the lack of respect persists well into adulthood, you're dealing with a major societal problem.
> it is by no means a universal trait in humanity
I didn't say it was universal. But it happens plenty enough that you cannot dismiss it when, for example, making public policy.
>" That is caused by putting disenfranchised, poor and troubled people there, and no longer giving a damn about them once they have a simple roof over their heads."
It is not an inherent nor universal trait of humanity.
It happens because people often feel uninvolved, disconnected, and self-concerned to a fault; they do not trust their neighbors, because they have been given no reason to do so. They have been propagandized for decades with the message that they must be self-sufficient, responsible adults, and the way you measure that is in wealth, and that in that regard they are, at best, in competition with their neighbor.
One consequence of this is not giving a damn about anything you do not own yourself, which is a sick mindset, a symptom of a sick societal order.
Most of the western world has adopted this neoliberal mindset, and it is making us increasingly more callous, the longer it goes on.
I am merely pointing out that this is in no way universal, and that the behavior you've observed is not caused by human nature, but rather by societal pressures and the forced state of constant ego-centered competition that people find themselves in.
Neoliberalism has made us callous and indifferent at best to the plight of our fellow human beings and the natural world.
They've all failed. Even when the only members are true believers in the idealism.
It's almost as if such goes against human nature :-)
If you want to talk about socialism specifically, the biggest drawback of socialism is that if you do it too well, you attract the attention of the US military industrial complex.
The entire modern history of Latin America exemplifies this issue.
Neoliberalism and capitalism do not tolerate alternatives to exist, because they undermine the condtructed narrative that no valid alternatives exist.
The US is hardly the only place where socialism has been tried. Last I checked, over 10,000 communes have been formed in the US since its inception. They all failed. None were put out of business by government intervention.
The Pilgrims tried a commune the first year (they starved). The Jamestown colony also attempted to work as a commune (they starved). The San Francisco Summer of Love commune lasted maybe 3 months.
Remember the Jonestown commune?
Israel has their kibbutzes, but they'd starve if they didn't receive generous taxpayer support from the Israeli government.
The great thing about the US is there are no laws against communes. You are free to go set one up with your like-minded friends. Nobody is going to try to stop you. People do it all the time.
But they never work. They never have, and never will, because of human nature.
They tend not to shout a lot about how great and awesome they are, because that sort of thing goes against the idea and mindset.
Perhaps you should look beyond your own ideology, and you'll see that there are a lot more and sometimes better ways to do things than your particular way.
Stole the land they use and supported themselves selling illegal drugs. Maybe they're also living off of government benefit checks, which is not self-sufficiency.
No mention that I could find on the turnover. 1 to 2 years is a typical stay in a commune, as people get tired of it and move on.
> sometimes better ways to do things than your particular way
If Freetown is your ideal, feel free to move there. No thanks from me. It's neighbors don't appear to care for it, either.
> cooperatives
Cooperative housing isn't the same thing as giving people free housing any more than a corporation means giving people free shares.
Georgism is specifically about land, not housing. The theory is that land value isn't much affected by investment of the landowner. Housing is, and that can be owned by individuals who then have a strong incentivize to take care of it.
Houston has zoning, they just don't call it zoning, and it's a mess. https://kinder.rice.edu/2015/09/08/forget-what-youve-heard-h...
The parent was talking about the government getting out of the way and letting people build denser neighborhoods. Japan has a good zoning model, based on population density and flexible land use.
In the U.S. zoning is used to restrict the supply of housing. Building codes exist for safety. What is the reason for zoning? To protect to investment of current homeowners and screw everyone else?
Nightclubs attract crowds, some of which will be rowdy, drunk and belligerent. They will urinate and defecate in doorways, cause property damage and may be violent, depending on the type of crowd the club attracts.
Subtract cost from benefit then add future resale value of property.
Before accumulating wealth, most people are interested in having a shelter.
Let's say someone has 50 years to live, from a point on. To have a shelter, it will cost him a = 50 * 12 * rent if he rents, b = x * 12 * rate if he buys a house and pays the mortgage, c = y * 12 * rate + 50 * 12 * land_rent if he buys just the house and lend the land.
So picking the smallest from a, b and c might be better for that particular individual.
Freehold properties trade ata significant premium to leasehold.