This distinction cannot be legislated. Amazon is absolutely in the right to shut down for a bit while they try to figure it out. They're also absolutely in the wrong for the way they've treated their employees over the past month. Both of these can be true! Its like everyone in this thread needs to pick a side, and the other side is crazy for thinking the way they do.
My hot take: having companies, that are so large that banning them is detrimental to society, is detrimental to society and extremely dangerous. We should never give so much power to one corporation. It should always be possible to reject a company.
I think the claim is that democracy means "the people" are in charge in some sense.
Of course, it's always been my experience that Starbucks has much better customer service than the DMV, so I'm not sure exactly how much that matters; it's not just that the people are nicer - the company actually cares somewhat about my opinions.
My opinions that Starbucks doesn't care about:
* How much foreign aid the US should send to Liberia
* Which model of surfboard is best
* Contract negotiations at the local school district
My opinions that Starbucks cares a lot about:
* How much I like their coffee in comparison to other coffee I drink
* How the purchase process went
* How much I like spending time in their store
Starbucks cares very much about my opinions when it matters to them. Whereas government, local or otherwise, couldn't care less about me.
> You actually likely have more influence over the running of your own local government than your local franchise coffee shop.
Clearly you haven't had to deal with an HOA, much less local government.
This is a justice decision. The government has nothing to do with it.
Interestingly, in the French wikipedia page for "gouvernement" [1], there is this paragraph :
Différence avec le terme anglais
En anglais, le mot « government » s'applique non seulement au gouvernement au sens où on l'entend en français, mais aussi aux collectivités territoriales et aux administrations publiques, aussi bien centrales que locales. Le concept le plus proche en français est donc celui de collectivité publique, qui englobe les institutions politiques qui incarnent directement les pouvoirs législatif, exécutif et judiciaire, ainsi que l'ensemble des administrations qui leur sont rattachées.
Which can be loosely translated as :
Difference with the english term
In English, the word "government" includes not only the executive governement like in French, but also all local and global public administrations. The closest concept in french is therefore "collectivité publique" which encompasses institutions for all Legislative, Executive, Judiciary powers, as well as all administrations under their authorities.
I learnt something new today.
What I can say is that personally, I definitely think I live in a country ruled by law. However separation of powers means there is no single entity exercising total control on this law: the executive branch proposes changes to the law, the legislative ratifies these changes (or not), and the judiciary branch is an arbiter of what happens when the existing law meets real life situations. While the limits between the executive and legislative branches can sometimes feel porous (especially when executive and legislative are controlled by a single political party, as is the case in both France and USA at the moment), the judiciary branch always felt more insular to me from the two others, at least in my country.
Another linguistic nuance to think about: in French, we are "ruled by law " but not "governed by law". In French, "gouverner" (to govern) is something that people do, not laws.
This is a bit of a brain dump, sorry. I wish I would have more definitive answers for you.
The difference here being that Americans perhaps prefer to refer to their country as land (in this case "of law", but on other occasions, "of opportunity", "of the free" and so on...) whereas the French would rather embrace the idea of the (welfare) state.
The former's legal system is one of common law (precedent based) whereas the latter is one of civil law (statute based).
Regardless -- the judicial in France has that same responsibility of ensuring the governing laws conform with the constitutional rights (via the Conseil Constitutionnel)
The difference though with the word government/gouvernement is probably, I agree, only one in language. Or what we would call in French "faux amis", or in English, "false friends" :)
Executive, Legislative, Judicial, are the 3 general area's of a functioning government
Most modern democracies do have an elected legislature, a legal system, an executive authority (whether it be an elected president or a parliamentary-style cabinet), and a career civil service (i.e., what in the US would just be called non-political-appointees in the Executive Branch), but the terms they use for these can differ, as can the exact nature of the separation of powers between them.
All modern functioning governments have the same 3 basic struture
These are all part of the government. My point says nothing about how the separation of powers between those government branches function, just that they exist and are all "government"
I am not sure how anyone can claim the court system of a nation is not part of "the government" which was the comment I replied to
Different countries have different words for things. It’s as simple as that.
What we call “soccer” in the US is called “football” in the UK. It doesn’t mean they’re two different things.
https://www.capital.fr/entreprises-marches/la-justice-demand...
> stop the delivery of non-essential products until is put in place an evaluation of the risks and measures necessary to protect the employees health
https://www.capital.fr/entreprises-marches/amazon-va-fermer-...
> order the online shop to limit itself to sell "essential products" (food, hygiene or medical) as long as the sanitary risks of the activity in the warehouse haven't been evaluated
Edit: better source
https://www.lesechos.fr/economie-france/social/coronavirus-l...
>But the American e-commerce giant was condemned to "restrict the activities of [its] warehouses to receiving goods, preparing and shipping orders for food, hygiene and medical products", "until the company has carried out, with the participation of employee representatives, an assessment of the occupational risks inherent in the Covid-19 epidemic in all of its distribution centres and the resulting measures".