> I can't help but wondering if the unlimited outside time under the guise of "exercise", but which people are clearly taking advantage of by going to hang out with friends in the park, has anything to do with it. Or perhaps it's the lack of masks in indoor areas like grocery stores that has prevented a bigger drop (in SF, only starting today has that finally changed).
Unlikely to both. Outdoor transmission is rare and I'd question if grocery store transmission (with heavy amounts of social distancing) is common given other countries historically being able to trace the majority of covid infection sources.
First off, as you allude to lockdowns are less effective than you think - we managed in norcal to drop from 1.43 to 0.98 (https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.12.20062943v...). Which is really good (uncontained to contained) in one sense, but shows you how slow containment is.
The containment difficulties lie in:
1. Household transmission still takes place after lockdown.
2. Huge variances within population sub-groups. R within folks with little human contact (WFH, etc.) was probably barely above 1 before the lockdown -- essential workers with heavy human contact already had the highest R and because they are still working (i.e. not really locked down), still have an R > 1 for quite some time.
3. Essential workers tend to live with other essential workers -- creating a multiple generation transmission chain (#1 and #2)
4. Group living outbreaks (symptoms of #3). e.g. in Santa Clara county, nursing homes are becoming a larger percentage of new cases over time. Something like 20% of new cases in the last 2 weeks. A single homeless shelter in SF is responsible for 20% of cases in the last 2 weeks.
5. At some point, you just are going to reach some level of herd immunity within the most susceptible groups -- in a sense the lockdown is more of a quarantining of a large percent of the population and letting everyone else get herd immunity.
CA definitely has high urgency in increasing testing - honestly, if you just hired a bunch of people to contact trace, you could probably go back to the March 15 pre-SIP world now.