If the government wants, they can do as companies have done (at least one of past employers did): End pensions going forward, everyone currently employed is grandfathered in, new employees get 401k with a match, new employees have a different salary step system that maxes out higher.
You're not arguing with someone who thinks the system is amazing as it is... it needs changes. But the teachers aren't the villains and they aren't living a life of grandeur.
Average Salary: $64,130(elementary), $60640(secondary)
Weeks of Vacation per Year: 15
(source: http://tinyurl.com/5dhgl8)
That's pretty good by today's standards. That's a salary of $1,733 PER WEEK that they work. I wouldn't consider a salary like that "accepting less money"
That's how the saying goes, right? ;)
But really, my point is that "teachers don't really get breaks because they spend the summer revamping their lessons" thing is an old tired meme that really needs to be critically examined.
http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2008/03/art4full.pdf
The fact is, teaching is an incredibly easy job. Teachers work less than other professionals, they get incredible vacations, and ridiculous job security.
I'd just like to point out that this statement isn't actually related to the others you made. In Western Australia it's been popular for a while due to the mining boom to go and get a fly in/fly out job in one of the mining towns. The pay is fantastic and the time off is good. This does not correlate to being "an easy job".
I could say that it is "easy to do a bad job", but when is that not the case?
Anyhow, just wanted to point that out. Not after an argument :)
And according to the bls the average american works about 34 hours last time I checked.... So teachers still work more!
The average American also doesn't get 12-15 weeks vacation.
The vacation time is indeed high (most of my family falls closer to ~12 weeks than 15). BUT, they also work more than most people I know. They leave the house at 6am, get back around 4 or 5pm, and then work on lesson plans for a few more hours. On the weekends, its grading.
So, they make almost 20% less and probably work a good 20% more per day (which makes the vacation time a wash).
A "pretty good" salary will only, at best, attract "pretty good" educators. If you have truly great teaching ability, there's more money to be made outside of the public education system.
They are passionate and knowingly traded money for good benefits. And then people throw the benefits in their face and say they deserve less money. Mind boggling!
You summed it up well, and this is what my whole post was alluding to, about whether people want the best system or the cheapest system. Policy seems to speak to the latter.