Hacker News Reader

Comment by foota | Hacker News Reader

So like... why doesn't someone just fill a reservoir or something?

That's what the strategic petroleum reserve in Louisiana is. They filled massive salt domes with crude oil. The salt keeps away bacteria that can foul the oil.

Well, that's a little more involved than a reservoir, in fairness. Makes me wonder though if we might see something like this pop up in the private sector in case this happens again. Even a tens of millions of dollar investment in storage would look reasonable alongside the potential profit having millions of barrels of storage would bring right now.

You have to dig a hole before you can fill it.

Backhoes are cheap. Maybe environmental issues? I imagine someone would have a problem if I just dug a hole and filled it.

> Maybe environmental issues?

Amongst others. It's not enough to just dig a hole in the ground, you have to make sure it doesn't seep into the ground as well. In addition, you have the always present risk of fire...

Unfortunately, right now it seems that there is incentive out there for oil to "go missing" for a profit -- presumably at the cost of the environment. I'm curious if anyone is thinking about trying to replace their fracking fluid with oil for a while...

Why don't the producers turn down the output? Does it cost more money to produce less? Is it mutually assured destruction? A game of chicken? This is so weird.

I heard on NPR yesterday that oil producers are concerned that output will be dampened by "turning down the output" because it can make flow rates lower when they reopen.

@recursive, I read here that there are contractual obligations in play. Search for jofer@'s answer.

I mean for a "personal" amount of oil, I suppose a backhoe would do. But, to change the front month price, you have to actually store a significant fraction of world oil production (1-2%?). I don't think a backhoe is going to cut it. Then you have to somehow make sure it doesn't plume into the ground water, which is impossible absent very specific geological features or somehow lining the world's largest open pit mine with an impermeable barrier.

You don't need to change the price, you just need to sell a contract for the future and deliver the oil then.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com