How the iPad can revolutionize music notation software
concertwindow.com
concertwindow.com
Further, a finger is a very imprecise input device. For music, precision is very important. Even a mouse is not precise enough for lots of things I do when I use DAW software.
Music notation is one place where I think pen-based input would be useful. It's precise and the input language is tightly scoped enough that the recognition problem is solvable. There's also no existing system that lets you input musical notes in any faster way. Recording-based apps (midi or otherwise) are always at the mercy of the performer. And unless you're superhuman (I'm not), you have to spend a long time quantizing and correcting the transcribed rhythm. It's real bummer. I would much rather scrawl the notes and know that they'll be nicely typeset out the other end.
One word: Keyboard.
This is one thing that I really love about soundtrackers (e.g. renoise[1]). You just type in your notes while seamlessly tabbing between different tracks/instruments. This makes experimentation faster and more pleasant than any other method I've come across.
It is sad that clumsy point-and-click interfaces are still the norm in most music software. Dragging around little rectangles on a grid is horrible.
[1] http://www.renoise.com/uploads/images/screenshots/rns25matri...
In terms of precision, I find the iPad to be plenty accurate, for these purposes anyway. The staff would have to be blown up a bit, but after that I don't see note accuracy being a problem. Plus, this would probably be a more limited program and wouldn't be as applicable to professionals who need that pixel-by-pixel level of accuracy (think finger painting vs. photoshop...).
It seems absurd to me that you would enter notes with the normal keyboard or the mouse or by tapping. What am I missing?
A midi keyboard takes up space. It also takes up more space the better it gets. If you want a 3 or 5 or 7 octave keyboard, you need to have that sort of room in your work area. Imagine an entire piano keyboard on your desk. Even a smaller keyboard takes up more space than another regular computer keyboard, and having a second one of those is difficult enough to work with.
Space issues aside, there's the issue of workflows. I've yet to find a music notation program with an anything approaching an elegant flow. For each passage of music that you'd like to write, there are a ton of variables that need to be expressed and recorded, and the midi keyboard only handles a few of these. You need to capture pitches of multiple notes (chords), durations, accents, articulations, voicing (for multiple parts on the same staff, as in choral music), dynamics, and many other things. Many of these are optional, and only used when needed, but even the most fundamental ones are often a chore to enter. A midi keyboard is great for entering note pitches, but as you described, playing in time (at speed) seems to be the only way to avoid entering all the note-lengths by hand. Playing in time has its own problems, too. You have to match the data to a grid structure. But the grid structure needs to be strict enough to catch the subtleties of the performance, and flexible enough to compensate for human-error. Otherwise, you'll be back to manual data-entry to correct all the parsing mistakes. These constraints also depend largely on the person playing the keyboard. On the other hand, an alternating two-step process isn't any faster with a midi keyboard than a computer keyboard.
Midi keyboards were not created for data entry. They were created for live performance, controlling other dedicated devices that created music, like synthesizers. They've been co-opted to enter data for notation, and while they can accelerate the process somewhat, there are shortcomings on the software side. It is also largely dependent on the type of music being transcribed.
I am very much in favour of an iPad notation program. I've been thinking about that since last summer, but I haven't had time to make one myself. If someone tackles this problem and comes up with an elegant solution, they'll have no noteworthy competition on either side of the PC/Post-PC divide. Pun intended.
I'm actually working on a startup that's looking to solve this problem, and we're fully confident that good, affordable, and simple yet well-thought-out music notation software is something that musicians everywhere are going to have a huge sigh of relief over. We're even applying to the summer YC session in hopes of accomplishing this faster :)
oh, and our url is http://www.tabrat.com by the way (still only a splash page though).