A history of FLICC: techniques of science denial
crankyuncle.com
crankyuncle.com
I don't think we should give the general public even more tools to simplify problems and conversations. Modern science is exploring very complex and chaotic problems, involving a huge number of various phenomenons interacting with each other and try to build a correct view of the result.
Sometimes, "Cherry picking" is exactly what we need to show a problem in a theory. Other times, there are structural problems for why a disproved theory keeps being taken into account (such as funding, or other potential conflict of interests), and it's not being a conspirationnist to talk about them.
All what matters in the end, is whether the person raising an issue is somewhat qualified enough to give an interesting perspective, and if that person is honest.
This kills any chance of having a sensible debate and there is no doubt it is very effective if that is the intended effect. It is a net negative in all other senses.
So, apart from applying labels to my response - and with that showing proof of the original premise I was trying to make - do you have a more constructive response? What, in your opinion, is the good done by attaching negative labels to concepts or persons? Can this be used in constructive ways or is it, as I propose, just a way to silence critics? As far as I can see it only serves to polarise the discussion and will cause people to throw up (virtual) barricades from behind which they can throw epithets at each other. My position is that there is far too much of this labelling and epithet-throwing and far too little sensible discussion where people of differing opinions get to meet each other to try to defend their positions in the open, without those barricades. Anything which will lead to more polarisation is in my opinion a net negative and as such something to try to keep out of the discourse.
> They probably thought it smart to use the same acronym pattern as SLAPP
Nope. Read the original article: FLICC comes from over a decade of research into the taxonomy of science denial. The author explicitly says that, in 2013, they coined FLICC as an attempt to categorize and simplify their presentation.
I don't see why I should be "constructive" or engage in "sensible debate" with you. Your approach isn't "simpler". I am not allowed to say that you did not read the original article, but I do think that you skimmed and did not engage with the bulk of its content or conclusions.
Do you have a position, other than the mind-reading dismissal that you started with?