Aren't flippant comments of this type also a virulent form of DKE?
Aren't flippant comments of this type also a virulent form of DKE?
1. The author can tell what is expertise based on the words spoken, the quality of the material produced. But then they'd need to be an expert themselves.
2. The authors defines expertise purely in terms of credentialism. Someone works at university X and not university Y, therefore they are experts and anyone else isn't.
As they mock people who engage in "armchair epidemiology" it's not (1), so it must be (2). But it's that absence of critical thinking that deserves to be flattened. It's an attitude of "don't think just obey" - the exact thing that a university education supposedly trains out of people. Supposedly. It's how Google ends up deleting videos of doctors because they aren't "experts" in health or disease, whilst leaving the pronouncements of people who can write R up.
You could argue these writers are implicitly claiming to be meta-experts, that is, they have superior understanding of the nature and location of expertise than other people do, although they don't. But I guess this sort of subjective argument is why I don't like Dunning-Kruger as a concept. Especially given that it's an output of social psychology, a field that started to collapse once outsiders from other fields i.e. non-experts started critically thinking about the content of psychology papers. Seems kind of ironic.
I don't deny there is some truth to it, but it seems perfectly suited for gaining traction through the Twitter mobs...
You mean the highlight that medium applies automatically based on user behavior and the author has no part in controlling?