Of course that does leave is with the authority of guilds in each area. They get to define who is a member and who is not, and where the research money goes within each area.
The major problems I find with this approach is that we end up letting the experts decide things that they are not experts in, and we have to trust their own policing.
They cannot within their own guild decide what tradeoffs society should make, it necessarily requires more than one expert opinion, and there's no way to say the concerns of one group must outweigh that of another. It's always a political decision by someone who isn't an expert in every field.
As for their own policing, there are plenty of examples of the experts being wrong. How a non-expert is gonna fix that I don't know, but not having external oversight is a due diligence failure.