All of my experiences with Nike are it's either overpriced garbage, or very expensively priced good stuff, but not good enough that it makes it worth the marginal cost over what's at Costco.
Sweatpants, screw that - I’ll quote Macklemore here, “$50 for a t-shirt, that’s just some fucking ignorant shit,” - go buy them from freaking Wal-Mart - who is going to see you in them anyways but your partner - but Nike’s core business is shoes, and my God, they do it exceptionally well.
That turns me off from buying Nike, as I want to reward brands that are consistent quality at whatever price, but Nike is betting they can get more revenue by using price discrimination to target different customers with the same brand.
It depends on the product.
Lately I've seen a lot of items on brand stores lately that are cheaper than in any online marketplace, with the added benefit of being 100% guaranteed to not get something that's fake/used/Amazon/knockoff.
The first place was a Nike store and not a retailer that you had purchased your last pair from?
I suppose it depends on how much importance you place on having a varied wardrobe. For me, past the age of 25 I could no longer care about spending hours in a mall trying on different brands, comparison shopping, and figuring out the fit.
If Brand A is of suitable quality, price and fit, I'm buying Brand A for as long as they keep making that article of clothing.