Putting partisan politics aside, I’m not sure how a rational person can look at this and conclude that it leads to fair elections.
Putting partisan politics aside, I’m not sure how a rational person can look at this and conclude that it leads to fair elections.
It's a fact that voter turnout across the US is far too low. It has many causes, some political (like votes getting implicitly suppressed via brazen gerrymandering) and some not (like ballots just not being the easiest things to fill out), and some in-between (like indirect obstacles that make it difficult for some minorities to vote). The idea here seems to be to remove as many obstacles as possible to increase voter turnout. Of course if that happens to help your party then you'll like it and probably support it, and if it happens to help the other party then you'll dislike it and probably be against it. But at least on its face, it has a bona fide goal that any political party that seeks legitimate elections should be supporting. Compare that to brazenly unfair practices like the extreme gerrymandering we see that are clearly solely designed to manipulate election outcomes (and which might even discourage people from voting in the first place) and I think you can imagine why a "rational person" might look beyond the game rules when deciding fairness.
Without ballot harvesting, voter fraud is difficult to scale. It requires coordination among large groups of malicious actors. But if you allow individuals to submit ballots in bulk, the scalability problem is reduced such that one bad actor can have an outsized effect on the fairness of the election.
While I agree that increasing voter turnout is a noble goal, I do not agree it should be achieved “at all costs.” Everyone should vote, but everyone who does vote must know that their vote was counted, and that it was counted accurately. And nobody who did not vote should have a vote counted in their name. Ballot harvesting, IMO, seems to increase the difficulty of meeting these requirements of fairness.
My problem is with the idea of bulk ballot harvesting, where one person has the ability to carry a box of hundreds of ballots to a polling place. Absent any sort of chain of custody, which AFAIK does not exist, how can you be certain that person did not modify the ballots, or that they even gave them to other voters in the first place?
Compare this to the potential gain of ballot harvesting: increased voter turnout because people who could not submit ballots now can. Note that the cost of submitting a ballot is inserting it into a mailbox.
IMO, it is irrational to think there are more members of the population who are unable to submit a ballot into a mailbox, than the number of false ballots that a small group of malicious actors could submit.
In fact, it seems like any argument in favor of ballot harvesting is ameliorated by the ability to vote by mail. And in either case, I maintain that it’s crucial to introduce some system that allows provable chain of custody for ballots, so that results may be audited.
Gerrymandering does not affect whether or not you can vote. It affects which district your vote counts for.
Voter ID, where it exists, does not affect ballot harvesting because registering to vote, and actually voting, are two separate activities. Further, I highly doubt that anywhere with “onerous voter ID laws” also allows ballot harvesting, because if it does, how could the ID laws be enforced?
How we scale voting by mail in any way that protects the secrecy and security of the process eludes me.
Highly skeptical, and opposed to this, especially given the context in which the idea is proffered.
When the election is over, you should be able to use your receipt to verify that your vote was counted.
I wish there were a way to run an experiment.
Oh, there is.
Try this on a couple of test states and let one of us eat crow.
But in all seriousness, after the shenanigans during this administration (whichever side the reader fall on) let's not make big changes this election.
Non cynically, I guess the idea is it increases voter turnout? I say "guess" because I've just googled "pros of ballot harvesting," "arguments for ballot harvesting," and other varieties of the phrase, and have yet to find a real argument for it. And if the argument is increasing voter turnout, I'm not sure why it's necessary if the cost of voting is no more than dropping a ballot in your mailbox.
So I guess for those who can't make it to the mailbox?
Is there a state that allows vote-by-mail and doesn't allow family members to drop off ballots?
Assuming good faith, that would be a service to those voters who can't otherwise get to a polling place.
From my research, the outrage about votor fraud is completely overblown.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_North_Carolina%27s_9th_co...
Moreover, I'm from a state that regularly sees serious voting abnormalities[1]. Everyone knows the elections are rigged and nothing is ever done about it.
So no, I don't think undetected electoral fraud is implausible, any more than I think, say, undetected insider trading is implausible.
[1]: https://www.salon.com/2019/08/30/probe-of-missing-georgia-vo...
I never said anything about voter fraud; that was a non-sequitur introduced by the parent commenter.