[0]: https://www.theguardian.com/world/commentisfree/2020/apr/21/...
[0]: https://www.theguardian.com/world/commentisfree/2020/apr/21/...
Brazil normally has 3800 deaths per day [0] so, as Bolsonaro says, so what. Some of the sick and elderly dying a few months earlier does not warrant removing the livelihoods of everyone else.
>Let's see where they are in a week or two (it'll be with 3x these death numbers and likely entering a lockdown de facto due to popular support for it).
Popular support is a function of media manipulation. And we know what types gravitate to that kind of work.
[0]:https://worldpopulationreview.com/countries/brazil-populatio...
I have no clue what you're getting at, fwiw.
As for the meat of your comment, exponential growth hits like a truck. 1/3 of Brazil's confirmed Covid-19 cases were confirmed last week. In general that means the death rate, which lags infection rate by a week or so, is based on 100K infected, not 150K. So this time next week we'll see 1000 per day. The week after, 1500 per day, actually probably more as hospitals get overwhelmed.
> Some of the sick and elderly dying a few months earlier does not warrant removing the livelihoods of everyone else.
And what of the hundred plus people under thirty and the 1000 plus people under 60 who have died from covid-19 in Brazil so far? And the 100 plus people under thirty and the 1000 plus additional people under 60 who will die from covid-19 in Brazil in the next week?
>I have no clue what you're getting at, fwiw.
Basically the kind of people that on any given day (it switches to a new subject every few weeks) are whining(/bullying) about feminism, gay rights, misogyny, bullying, #metoo, etc etc are now causing the collapse of the world economy.
>As for the meat of your comment, exponential growth hits like a truck.
They say that but hasn't happened. And it's not like the virus is going disappear everywhere before the lockdowns need to be let up so there really is no point in having them in the first place. People just need to soldier on.
>And what of the hundred plus people under thirty and the 1000 plus people under 60 who have died from covid-19 in Brazil so far? And the 100 plus people under thirty and the 1000 plus additional people under 60 who will die from covid-19 in Brazil in the next week?
As shown in the previous link, 1 person net is added to the population of Brazil every 21 seconds. That's the real emergency.
It's happening right before your eyes: To repeat myself, 1/3 of Brazil's confirmed Covid-19 cases were confirmed last week. That's exponential growth. If that trend continues, and without intervention it will, a week from now, Brazil will be over 200K confirmed cases. A week later, well over 350K.
For comparison, Brazil is about where Italy was on March 20th. They had instituted a nationwide lockdown on March 9th, and still had peak deaths (at around 900/daily) a week later on the 27th and 28th. For brazil at this point, that's basically unavoidable.
So just checking, at what point do you believe a lockdown is reasonable? When covid causes more deaths than every other cause of death combined? Because that's just a month away.
> As shown in the previous link, 1 person net is added to the population of Brazil every 21 seconds. That's the real emergency.
I see no reason to consider this an emergency. If anything, we can expect the birth rate to begin decreasing as Brazil stabilizes. Of course that won't happen if a virus sweeps through and kills a bunch of people.
> Basically the kind of people that on any given day (it switches to a new subject every few weeks) are whining(/bullying) about feminism, gay rights, misogyny, bullying, #metoo, etc etc are now causing the collapse of the world economy.
I'm sorry you feel this way. I wish you happiness and peace in these hard times.
I think lockdowns of the entire population does more harm than good. I say protect the vulnerable and let the rest self-isolate if they feel the risk is warranted.
After all this ain't the Black Death plague, it's a bad cold that has a zero effect on most that get it.
Basically we've reverted to centralized control of the economy so it's failing like communism.
>>1 person net is added to the population of Brazil every 21 seconds. That's the real emergency.
>I see no reason to consider this an emergency.
It's an ecological emergency, take a look at the Amazon.
>I'm sorry you feel this way. I wish you happiness and peace in these hard times.
Yeah you're real smug working for Google aren't ya. Tell that to all the business owners, unemployed workers, and starving masses.
If you feel the need to lash out at someone, I'm a better target than those facing more hardship. But yes, while I'm fortunate, I know many people who aren't in as stable a situation, most of them however recognize the necessity of that hardship.
It's an unfortunate situation yes, but the alternatives aren't better.
> After all this ain't the Black Death plague, it's a bad cold that has a zero effect on most that get it.
You're right, it's more like the Spanish flu, which killed 3% of the world's population at the time, or 180 million people today. That's not a sacrifice we should be willing to make.
> Basically we've reverted to centralized control of the economy so it's failing like communism.
No. This is comically incorrect. In some sense there is more centralized economic control sure, but well first of all that isn't communism, but second of all, that centralized control is succeeding at its goal, which is to reduce the death toll of the virus. You may not share the same value system, but that's Ok with most people, who don't value profit over lives. Granted this would be easier to bear for everyone if the US had a stronger social support system.
> It's an ecological emergency, take a look at the Amazon.
I don't see how deforestation in the amazon, which usually has to do with comsumerism in places like the US, has anything to do with the population of Brazil.
> I say protect the vulnerable and let the rest self-isolate if they feel the risk is warranted.
I read this as you saying you want some of the most vulnerable populations among us to sacrifice their safety and quality of life for the rest of us, while you yourself are unwilling to do the same for them. Is that correct?
People have to start speaking up against the overly politically-correct or we end up in situations like the current lock-down.
>It's an unfortunate situation yes, but the alternatives aren't better.
You can look at Sweden and see that is not true. Only .03% of population has died. That is 3% of 1%. [0]
It's not as if deadly flu's and other nasty diseases that people have to avoid naturally are not going around all the time anyway.
>You're right, it's more like the Spanish flu, which killed 3% of the world's population at the time, or 180 million people today. That's not a sacrifice we should be willing to make.
It's not killing 3% of the population. More like 3% of 1%.
~60M people die every year worldwide. Coronavirus barely moves the needle.
>I don't see how deforestation in the amazon, which usually has to do with consumerism in places like the US, has anything to do with the population of Brazil.
I live in the Amazon. Humans are like a plague of locusts, cutting down all trees and killing everything that moves. Deforestation is mainly from the poor doing slash and burn. And from people just trying to earn a living (the wrong way), more and more of them every day. (FWIW I'm here showing a better way. ie reforestation)
>So you want some of the most vulnerable populations among us to sacrifice their safety and quality of life for the rest of us? But you're unwilling to do the same for them? That feels rather selfish to me.
No I said protect the vulnerable and let the rest self-isolate if they feel the risk is warranted. As in, don't bring the virus into old folks homes.
You talk as if you think the common cold disappears after people hide in their houses for awhile.
And as if the world can go on shut down indefinitely.
Going on 8 wks of shut down here and it's a joke. Idiots copying the stupid.
[0]: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/sweden/
The capitol of sweden is being hit as hard as NYC. And that's despite many social distancing measures in place. The idea that sweden isn't being impacted negatively is wishful thinking.
> It's not as if deadly flu's and other nasty diseases that people have to avoid naturally are not going around all the time anyway.
The resignation that shit's bad, so we should let it get worse is fatalistic and untenable.
> And as if the world can go on shut down indefinitely.
Indeed it can't, no one is proposing that.
No actually in both cases it's a miniscule percentage of the overall population. People should be looking at percentages, because absolute values just cause lockdown hysteria.
>The resignation that shit's bad, so we should let it get worse is fatalistic and untenable.
It's not resignation, it's indignation at the over-reaction to this practically common virus.
>> And as if the world can go on shut down indefinitely.
>Indeed it can't, no one is proposing that.
So the whole exercise is pointless because the virus is going to do it's rounds anyway.
Yes, .2% of NYC residents are dead from Covid. Another % or so will likely have lifelong consequences. And that's with social distancing. Without, we'd be looking at 1% and 5-10%. And many of that 5-10% are young.
Looking solely at deaths doesn't tell the whole story.
> So the whole exercise is pointless because the virus is going to do it's rounds anyway.
Sure sounds like resignation to me. But no, the measures being taken now allow us to understand more about the virus and ways to prevent it. We're seeing lockdowns end and lighten, replaced by more lighweight measures like mask requirements and contact tracing.
We could have had this happen weeks ago and have been done at a fraction of the cost, but the US response was delayed due to the same kind of head burying as is happening in Brazil now.
> Sure sounds like resignation to me.
No it's just reality. I've had a dengue a few times. Some die. People are working to fix it. We don't shut down everything for it.
You've resigned to the collateral damage caused from the economic shut down. I have not. Maybe if you had your own business you'd have a different opinion on the matter.
I'm not, I absolutely believe the economic shutdown could be handled much better. I believe that a certain party doesn't want to actually respond appropriately, because it would violate the narrative they push about government incompetence. I wish they valued lives more than they do, unfortunately they feel that sacrificing either those to economic plight or disease is worth the value of the idea that government is incompetent.
Either that or they are incompetent. Either way they should be removed.
> 0.2% dead and everyone loses their minds.
May I remind you of 9/11. Covid so far has been a 9/11 in NYC every week for 3 straight weeks. So yeah, declaring war seems par for the course.
Hardly. Those are the two countries that have resisted shutdown of their economies and are showing negligible percentage of deaths.
And the World Food Programme has stated that the coronovirus shutdown is putting ~265 million at risk of famine and "as our Executive Director told the UN Security Council on Tuesday, we could be looking at 300,000 people dying every day for three months" [0]
>Brazil is early into this and seeing a high rate of transmission (R0 2.8). We really don't know enough in this country's case what the end result will be in terms of mortality.
Yeah. Perhaps it will bump up from .005% of their population dying to .03%. Mostly the already sick and elderly.
[0]:https://www.dw.com/en/world-food-program-act-now-to-prevent-...