If the drop into poverty as people lose jobs create slums, gangs, and muggings, there will be a lot more deaths, and those will also offset the numbers.
So, even quality of life aside, I am not sure we come out ahead even on saving lives.
I would like data though, since anyone can speculate. Can someone point to real data?
Not if they get counted as a COVID death. You better believe that drug overdose death is getting a test if there's federal reimbursement in play.
Every % rise of unemployment in Europe during the financial crisis resulted in a 3.5% drop in all cause mortality, and that includes a ~35% increase in suicides. We can probably extrapolate that for a scenario where business as usual also kills a good amount more people due to a pandemic.
Clearly the US, being the US, could be different due to cultural differences in how the poor and underemployed are treated.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S009174351...
I recognize that you're making a joke here, but that's categorically not true. Mental-health related deaths have gone up, and will continue to go up. A lot.
Ok, i'm only being mildly sarcastic. Flashbacks from stories told by a grandfather and father. Honestly, if someone told me last year I would be typing this in a discussion on HN on this topic I would have told them they were insane. And here we are, people on HN actually discussing "stay at home" as if it was a not a big deal.
These are the people who work for Google and Facebook and Instagram and Twitter? It horrifies me. It should terrify the population.