The New Yorker has done a lot to try, for good or ill, to make the digital experience as similar to the paper one as possible.
My guess is the enormous page is part of this effort.
I think it's pretty misguided in the browser -- or, at least, that they've pushed well past the point of diminishing returns on it -- but they are to be commended for the consistency and depth of availability.
Another factor is probably (again, I'm guessing) that their preferred method of digital consumption is their own apps, where issues are rendered digitally exactly like their paper counterparts, with ads and all. Given the primacy of text at the New Yorker, this actually works out really well. (It's probably worth noting that the New Yorker NEVER does that thing where an article is "continued on page 102" or whatever, which probably makes this work better.)
It's definitely cool that this whole-magazine rendering is available (for subscribers) not just for current issues, but for the entire archive going back 95 years. That's neat.