Refreshing to see some pressure for democracy to resume.
Refreshing to see some pressure for democracy to resume.
In the U.S. it's well-accepted, long-established constitutional law that presidential executive orders simply do not and cannot have the force of statutory law without connection to an enabling statutes. The Republican Guarantee clause of the Constitution means that the States have to have separate legislative and executive branches of government, and by extension that gubernatorial EOs also can't have the force of statutory law without the support of statutes -- otherwise Governors could rule without legislatures, as kings, which would be decidedly not a republican form of government.
As Powell said yesterday, 40% of households making $40K or less lost their jobs in March. This is crushing those most vulnerable, economically.
In other words, I think you completely fail to understand the impact this is having on the poorest people. If they close schools again God help the single parents..
(EDIT: Though not in this case! From the opinion: "This case is about the assertion of power by one unelected official, Andrea Palm, ..."[0].)
But in this case the issue is that a governor cannot impose law without the legislature. Wisconsin's legislature still sits -- if not in session, perhaps the governor could call it into session -- and can pass legislation.
[0] https://www.wicourts.gov/sc/opinion/DisplayDocument.pdf?cont...
This is a strict increase in democracy.
To my knowledge, there was no such legislation. The order was issued by the executive.
Partisan judges felt the need to overturn that bill - despite the legislature retaining the power to override the executive, and to repeal that bill - if they could get 66% of the assembly behind it.
This is the opposite of a democratic process. The democratic process has checks and balances for dealing with a rogue executive - but it requires an overwhelming support of the legislature. Instead, this ended up being decided by unelected career bureaucrats.
The legislature granted specific emergency powers to the governor. Based on the decision, I don’t see the scope of those powers being met. (Specifically, the criminal consequences and open-ended timeline.)
And it’s the legislature, today, bringing the case against the executive.
> democratic process has checks and balances for dealing with a rogue executive - but it requires an overwhelming support of the legislature
This is true in no system with the rule of law. The judiciary also checks the executive.
[1] https://www.wicourts.gov/sc/opinion/DisplayDocument.pdf?cont...
No, the explicit holding in this case is that the executive has not been granted this power by the legislature.