Bad Washington Post Story on Apple and Google's Exposure Notification Project
daringfireball.net
daringfireball.net
Apple and Google have a huge amount of power when it comes to what capabilities they allow apps to use on their device. So when the article mentions “sovereign power” and “unbending stance”, it is referring to that. It is impossible for a user to run an app that collects tracing and location data in the background given the restrictions the OS puts in place. This definitely is better from a privacy standpoint, but it is these companies making the call that it’s better for society.
Google and Apple are the ones that decide what data is collected and who it is shared with. It is pretty remarkable how much faith we must have in them.
No, Google and Apple are one of a number of entities that have the ability to put a maximum on the data shared. Governments are free to pass laws that limit data collection and sharing (and some have!), and individual organizations are free to limit their collection and sharing. To an extent, individuals are also free to limit what data is collected about them, though I'll grant that this is difficult for many users.
Do you really want to go the route of compelling Apple or Google to collect data on behalf of a government?
A line of logic that goes, “in the absence of conclusive evidence, play it safe” doesn’t give you an answer for “track locations and surveil, to collect more data and answer questions better, versus collect a minimal amount of data in the interest of some other kind of safety called privacy.” There’s no universal rationalist approach to your opinion here. You have to decide whether to trust John Gruber or whatever health officials WashPo quoted.
RCT is a real line for people in medicine, at least for people who aren’t looking to make a buck developing a drug. In the same way health officials don’t strictly care if the stock market goes down, they wouldn’t strictly care if Google and Apple’s brand would be impacted by detailed location tracking. At the end of the day health officials, like the UCSF prof quoted here, just want people to be safe and healthy.
The counterpoint is, what do Apple and Google want? To do something? The appearance of doing something? They are not health organizations. John Gruber isn’t a doctor. These are different perspectives and goals, not an argument over how to achieve common goals. Why crank out and die on the hill of a giant company’s PR team?
If only it were so simple. Publicizing private data is a one-way operation that has longer term effects on safety and health, and we should certainly not do it without a very strong reason to do so. Health officials will not be accountable for the long term effects of their actions. Apple and Google will, so they are somewhat more incentivized to act to protect their users' privacy.
They are in part. Apple's "edge healthcare" products and services are an important aspect of the Apple experience.
[1] https://www.apple.com/healthcare/ [2] https://www.apple.com/healthcare/apple-watch/ [3] https://www.apple.com/healthcare/health-records/ [4] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208647
This should be at least user choice, if not decided at the ballot box. Certainly not by shareholders. Especially since it seems the app in question is, as a result, not very useful.