One can't help but think, maybe web stack makes it the easiest to build good looking apps that are responsive
The web stack is the easiest to hire for.
The web stack is the easiest to deploy to.
The web stack has the most inertia, so its substantial and glaring flaws actually get addressed, whereas other GUI stacks change at a much slower pace (for better or worse).
So I’m not sure this arguments outweighs the cost of having to maintain different native apps.
What I'm getting to is; if people wanted something better, something better would've come along already. Most developers are shielded by user ignorance, if users knew what happens behind the scenes at most banks, they wouldn't want to bank with them anymore. Same goes for almost every software system.
But a lot of my non-technical friends, many of them with much cheaper computers, definitely grumble about Slack and the like. The difference is much more noticeable on their hardware, and anyone I know who can get away with it prefers to use WhatsApp or, in some cases, Telegram.
Lock-in definitely plays a big role. If you already need to keep Slack open for your employer, you might as well use it for other things, for example.
I understand this point, and I definitely agree. But I'm also of the opinion that some of these companies wouldn't be as popular if they tried to build native apps from the start. They wouldn't be able to move so quickly, and would be restrained by money and resources. Of course, once you grow (Slack & Spotify) you should invest in making the experience as painless as possible.
However, not only am I starting to doubt this, I think it's even less of an issue for a startup that can afford at least a handful of developers.
First off, the few projects I've done with 'web tech' that had to be native-ish (cordova, so web apps as 'proper' apps on your phone) have made me more skeptical. Sure, at first it was nice to be able to build things using a stack I was mostly familiar with.
But not properly knowing the development and build tools for Android/iOS made me extremely uncomfortable. And if I'd bother mastering those, I might as well go for native.
Having to jump through various hoops to get something that felt as native as possible was difficult too.
And finally so many things were not part of my 'web developer toolset' anyways that I might as well have learned the native approach (notifications, any other integrations with the OS that web doesn't offer or doesn't offer on the major platforms).
I mostly came away from that experience wondering if the main reason why we do these things is a (somewhat) unreasonable fear of learning a new tech stack.
I can totally see the use case for Electron and Cordova and RubyMotion and so on. But for a sufficiently experienced developer it might already be preferable to just learn iOS and/or Android development, and for a company that can afford a handful of developers getting one of each, at first, should be doable.
But again, I could be wrong and it's just a growing feeling. Maybe I'm underestimating the amount of work needed to do native development. I haven't had the time to properly do so yet...
I agree with you on the tool set tho, I also felt quite uncomfortable not knowing how exactly React Native was doing all the things to make it work for Android / iOS, and sometimes it was extremely difficult to access native functionality.
At the end of the day, I don't know what the correct use case is, I see advantages to both.
It's death by a thousand cuts. You're probably not going to switch your MBP from 8GB to 16GB because of spotify/slack alone, but if you have four electron apps using 500MB each, you're missing a quarter of your memory. That may very well push you to get the option 16GB (+$100).
But it's true, he obviously doesn't care about the performance of his computer. Why should he, it's not his job to think about such things.
Even for big companies it's hard to organize multiple projects to be on the same level, especially if we are talking about some more arcane platforms where you have a hard time to find people with enough experience.
In your opinion what do all the other companies have to gain with the added cost required to reach the same outcome?