Show HN: Common ownership between S&P 500 companies
quiverquant.com
quiverquant.com
This project was inspired by “The Problem of 12”, the fact that most public companies are increasingly being controlled by a small group of institutional investors: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3247337
There is compelling evidence that this shared ownership can lead to anticompetitive outcomes, such as lower wages and higher prices: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2427345.
My goal is to highlight the extent to which ownership of many competing companies is being concentrated among a small number of institutions, and spark discussion about this problem.
Let me know if you have any suggestions for improvements to the dashboard, or ideas for new projects for me to work on!
>"We are rapidly moving into a world in which the bulk of equity capital of large companies with dispersed ownership will be owned by a small number of institutions... It is not an exaggeration to say that even if this mega-trend begins to taper off, the majority of the 1,000 largest U.S. companies will be controlled by a dozen or fewer people over the next ten to twenty years." >- John C. Coates, IV, Harvard Law, "The Problem of Twelve"
The data on the page counteracts this point, nearly all the examples presented are of wealth management funds or holding companies, representing millions and millions of people. The #1 investor is literally Vanguard, the investor cooperative.
While funds like Vanguard are financed by investments from millions of people, the leaders of those funds control the voting power of all of their shares.
This could cause anticompetitive behavior, when the same funds/holding companies have large stakes in all of the players within a given industry.