Their donations might just not be accepted.
The willingness is what's important.
Organ donation at death is entirely risk free to the donor. They have literally nothing to lose from it.
http://thelegalgeeks.com/2014/11/13/stealing-corpses-and-obs...
We are not property of the State therefore, society has no claim on it.
If we are property of the State then all we're disagreeing on is the moment where their claims supersede our own.
The moment of death is a convenient but negotiable/re-definable point: "Well, they're brain dead already.." or "Well, their quality of life.." or "Their chance of survival.."
Or to put it another way: Do you want want [your least favorite politician] writing this policy?
You're trying to force this into a "We {are|aren't} property of the state". Both sound completely wrong to me, on multiple levels. It's a TypeError. You're applying words in ways that don't match.
(You might as well try to convince me that "Beethoven's 5th is either color, or black-and-white". No, those are both wrong. I'm not going to agree with any conclusions you reach starting from either condition.)
Humans aren't "property" (of themselves, or anything else). And the state doesn't own something today just because it may own it after your death (e.g., when a person without a will dies, their house may go to the state, but that in no way means their house was "property of the state" while they were alive, and definitely not that all houses are property of the state).
> Do you want want [your least favorite politician] writing this policy?
Again, that sounds like a fallacy that's trying to goad people into a false choice. I don't want my least favorite politician writing any government policy. There is no framework yet conceived under which a malicious administrator would not be able to cause great harm by instituting a policy of their own design. That doesn't mean all such policies are inherently ill-conceived.
Blood is a funny case because we have a huge never-ending need for fresh blood, and a great number of people (est. 1/3 to 1/2 the population) are eligible to donate, yet very few do. Globally we're so desperate for supply that, even though the WHO has set a goal of 100% non-paid volunteer donors due to safety concerns, we do still have to pay people, and America sells a lot of blood overseas to all those other countries who are too cautious to pay their donors cash outright.
Tons of people are perfectly willing to donate blood. That's not even the problem. In the aftermath of a disaster, blood centers near the disaster area often have so many donors they have to throw some of it away. People are not that afraid of needles, or unwilling to help their fellow humans. They just don't, usually.
Living in my developed country with all of its benefits has costs. I pay taxes to help fund the general welfare, and may be called to serve on a jury, or even go fight in a war. Calling on a few people to give blood doesn't sound too onerous to me.
I don't claim to have the answer, but I think everyone agrees we can do a lot better than what we've got now.