I think it's strange you are saying this idea of remote work is a "single formula". If anything, refusing to do things differently is more like a "single formula" in my mind.
Maybe you think differently about this, but I can't fathom a real-world scenario where tapping into all qualified candidates in the entire world vs tapping into all qualified candidates within a 20-30 mile radius from my HQ could be even close in comparison.
Obviously we won't decide who is "right" here in a forum. But I will be interested to follow what happens to the companies who weren't prepared for this and companies who already were.
I anticipate some major reshuffling will be happening in the coming years. The companies who built their entire culture around on-site teams vs companies who built infrastructure and culture around acceptance of work from home. Companies with large balance sheets will be able to hide it for some time, but their unpreparedness will begin to show within 1-3 years I think.
This is all given the premise that things don't 100% go back to "normal".