I think making the code available is good, but I think we should be careful how we use the term "reproducibility". Pulling your repo and running it had better give the same results, but it's not the same sort of thing as building my own experimental setup according to a paper's specification. The latter gives more room for variability such that successful replication speaks more strongly to the robustness of the result, and also puts human brain power next to each step of the process in a way where weirdness might be noticed.
Replication should probably involve reimplementation, if it's to carry its traditional weight. In the event that we fail to replicate, though, having the source code for both versions is likely to be hugely informative.