Companies don't make billion dollar purchases with no due diligence with just one person involved in making the decision. And they don't buy companies just to immediately write them down.
Amazon is one of the most successful companies in the world. They didn't get there by acting like children.
But no company makes billion dollar acquisitions without involving the entire C-suite in particular CFO/Legal and the Board. And they sure as hell don't do it without proper due diligence.
Sure.
Is there a chance that Amazon did not analyze it to death before making the decision?
Nope.
Heck, Microsoft bought Nokia, and then completely dismembered it.
It's entirely possible for someone in the higher floors in Amazon to convince themselves this is a good fit.
Maybe it's a good decision, maybe not. But it's never right to say it's a good decision because a successful company took it.
Yahoo would like a word.