I don't understand what worldview leads to the conclusion that any moderation of a private platform by a private entity is equivalent to government censorship.
> I don't understand what worldview leads to the conclusion that any moderation of a private platform by a private entity is equivalent to government censorship.
I didn’t say “government censorship”.
This is the most bizarre take on libertarian free speech absolutism that I've heard all week.
Nonsense. The Internet in general, and YouTube in particular did quite well for themselves for most of their existence, without any significant moderation.
You would have to pretty new to the internet to think that it would all collapse without heavy handed censorship.
I remember very clearly that up until about 2015 there was almost no moderation outside of spam, copyright infringement, or blatantly illegal stuff.
It would probably benefit these online communities to stop moderating and censoring stuff so much.
YouTube clearly is trying to gentrify their platform, and turn it into a sanitized short-form Netflix.
They pay media companies like MSNBC and Fox News to post clips of their shows, and heavily promote them.
They've driven many of the best content creators off of their platform. I used to really enjoy YouTube, but my favorite channels are constantly having to worry about their videos being deleted. They've been removing their old videos for fear of getting too many strikes, and moving to other, less good platforms.
> I don't understand what worldview leads to the conclusion that any moderation of a private platform by a private entity is equivalent to government censorship.
Well, when a platform becomes ubiquitous and powerful enough that only government can restrain it, then the question of people's general welfare comes up.
America has had these discussions before. We used to let oil companies, coal companies, rail roads, and phone companies become aggressive and destructive monopolies.
I think that at this point, calling YouTube "private" is not really correct. Not just do they heavily benefit from many government protections, but they are so big that they are not bound to market forces, and are essentially unaccountable to the public.
Corporations have no right to exist. And corporations that do not follow the rules certainly should not enjoy Section 230 protections. I don't think it is too much to ask that we be allowed to sue them if they don't follow the law.
And if you're suggesting every instance of moderation on Youtube's platform should be a civil or criminal matter, and that a court or some other agent of the state should decide on each matter rather than Google, how would that not still be censorship?
Also folks, keep in mind that I am absolutely not saying that the government should regulate every video on YouTube, I am only saying that YouTube should lose its special privileges if it wants to play that game itself. It is a critically-important distinction that I feel is being missed here.
It also adds noise to the discussion which detracts from the very real bad behavior that’s happening here.
You know that comment moderation on a privately owned website is both legal and protected by law, and in no way affects your free speech protections?
OK cool, that resolves the parent's objection. I did not know that.
> You know that comment moderation on a privately owned website is both legal and protected by law, and in no way affects your free speech protections?
Read up on the CDA and the special privileges granted by Section 230. I'm not at all suggesting that online moderation should be made illegal.
> I’m not at all suggesting that online moderation should be made illegal.
Maybe I misunderstood. What are you suggesting then? What is the problem, and how is tearing down section 230 going to solve that problem? You said you wanted porn and beheadings to be allowed, and made a claim above that moderation is censorship. That did sound to me like you’re against moderation, so help me understand what you meant.
BTW, what is making you think that section 230 has anything to do with YouTube's comment deletion here? It sounds like they claimed it was a mistake. Whether true or not, it doesn't sound like section 230 is being used as a defense. So is this discussion about section 230 a red herring?
The EFF is one of the strongest champions of freedom of speech online, and they disagree with you. https://www.eff.org/issues/cda230
FTFY.
Wait.