For me, the biggest value prop was that I could leave them anywhere and didn't have to maintain them. I could buy myself one, but then I'd need to take care of it and make sure it doesn't get stolen. I'm not sure I'm interested in that.
Yeah...that's kinda the problem. People who leave them anywhere. The scooter thing is a great example of how thoughtless people can be when offered convenience.
You can buy renters insurance or something similar for your bike. Mine is covered for a few bucks a month.
A few bucks a month is a lot of money. Try buying an annuity for a few bucks a month over the lifetime of the average bicycle and you're probably doubling the cost of the bike.
It's not like bike share renting is cheap compared to owning a bike either.
It is if you only use it periodically. If I was commuting daily on a bike, I'd buy one. But I was mostly doing ~1 ride / month for tourist-y reasons.