50% of homicides are brought to justice in Chicago, but the remaining half are not normally distributed in terms of crimes per criminal. ~50 people are responsible for half of the unsolved homicides in Chicago.
I am not going to be able to provide a direct reference for this claim. My point is that the rate of severe crimes can be efficiently diminished by targeting professional criminals and the networks that enable them. Policing minor crimes is counterproductive because the harmful side effects of policing (racial and social injustice, legal costs, adversity between police and citizens) are greater than the benefit to the community of removing misdemeanors like vandalism and drug use. You might say that broken windows policing is not Pareto efficient.
The first can get you trust needed to identify your major criminals, the second creates an alliance of presumed criminals that shares little with the police.
What does this mean? If we know who did them, how are they unsolved?
> “Major crime complaints,” such as murder, rape, robbery and felony assault. > ... > The scientists found that civilian complaints of major crimes dropped by about 3% to 6% during the slowdown.
>“The cessation of proactive policing corresponds roughly to the relative decline in crime that earlier research attributed to the effects of mass incarceration,” the authors noted.
The article is careful to include the researcher's caveats; ant further study would have a better chance to address the question of a decline in major crime reporting rate. However if somebody tried to report a major assault and was turned away from reporting, I'd hope that the story would get reported on. And if people were assaulted but more fearful to go to the Police than they were before, hopefully there would also be reports. But with the police harassing individuals less, I would think people would be no less likely to go in.
And of course murders are pretty much impossible to not report. But in the time period there may not have been enough to notice a statistically significant decline.