> It's true for surgical masks, whose purpose is to prevent the wearer from spreading the infection around; you can apply social distancing in lieu of these masks, which is not possible for medical staff.
This isn't an argument that they're ineffective for stopping transmission. It's an argument that there are alternatives. And many people aren't/weren't able to fully social distance either, which is why masks were (and are) still useful. Recommending against N95 use while encouraging the use of cloth barriers was an easy, obvious step to take that our structurally incompetent public health agencies failed to do (among many, many other failings).
> It's also true for respirators, which require specialized training to be worn correctly, which is something the medical staff has, and regular citizens don't.
A California study showed that 65%[0] of healthcare workers apply respirators incorrectly; the population baseline is 72%. Your argument proves too much, unless you think that respirators are useless for doctors and all the complaints about PPE shortages were pointless whining.
The point here is that the evidence we had in February and early March was more than enough to make a sane decision on masks, reducing spread and individual risk while not exacerbating hospital shortages (in and of itself a symptom of institutional incompetence). It's beyond me why people are bending over backwards to avoid admitting the institutional stupidity the early days of the pandemic were wracked with.
[0] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10656351/