The other way to do this would be to over engineer, have more conservative testing, etc. But Musk has been clear that they've explicitly chosen a strategy of fast iteration, and breaking things instead. And that's one of the primary things that gives them an edge over NASA.
I'm not saying the failure was intended, I'm saying the reason there are so many failures because they opted to go hard and fast, while government funded shops like NASA can't afford to have such a high failure rate because of the optics and politics. This modality to R&D isn't at all unique to aerospace and is more of a business/management issue so I'm not sure why you think an engineer would have anything more meaningful to say.
As Kelly Johnson of skunkworks said, you can't have innovation unless you are prepared to see failures.
Failures are not clear evidence that the innovation strategy is working as planned.
What there is clear evidence of, is you generally reach your goal faster if you're more risk tolerant. And that's very well understood by now. Various r&d folk from NASA have also said that they wish they could go harder and faster. But because they're micromanaged by congress, every failure is very expensive politically.
Definitely not true.
> What there is clear evidence of, is you generally reach your goal faster if you're more risk tolerant.
If budget is unlimited, perhaps. In real life, not so much.
If a rocket never fails, it means it's too heavy (overdesigned.) That's why Musk is ok with failures early on - he wants that data.
So whether a destructive test is intentional or not, it does provide data for the next iteration.
It's irrelevant if somebody "plans" or "hopes" for a new rocket to work tomorrow. It either works, or doesn't.
This assertion is utterly absurd. These guys aren't the jackass crew just figuring out what to blow up next just for kicks.
Please, do not add more noise to the discussion.
Its still a Musk corp, and as I was told at Tesla 'Elon gets, what Elon wants.' Its really odd philosphy but not entirely surprising, because I was going for Operational Support roles, not Engineering where its understood he has full reign, and it was felt in those department's leads/directors.
As for SN4, well, what's the saying: Progress is messy. Aerospace has lots of failures. Onto SN5!
You put forward perfectly reasonable observations and it is frustrating when someone tries to silence others using the appalling Credentials Fallacy.
It is perfectly logical to say at the macro level our "take risks, move fast" strategy will produce more failures, whilst at the micro level being very disappointed at each failure.
Now, if this was a manned mission with life at stake I would expect the risk approach to be modulated accordingly. But even so, astronauts are not civilian passages and even they knowingly embrace flying at high risk. It would be interesting to know how (and if) SpaceX has approached derisking manned flight. Because the PR from blowing up humans is not good whether you're NASA or a private company.