I mean, I've seen understaffed, shitty-service companies since I was a kid. How is this unique? Fuck them all.
I mean, I've seen understaffed, shitty-service companies since I was a kid. How is this unique? Fuck them all.
Democratizing a thing mainly involves scaling it, and scaling things rapidly is a difficult task. Having only a few qualified people ready for a task of this magnitude is not surprising to me.
So what you're saying is, there is this hugely valuable application that has "revolutionized" things for a large fraction of the population, but it's perfectly normal that Google can't be bothered to put more than a piddly number of people on it?
If it's really that valuable, Google should not handle it in this half-assed fashion. They should charge money for it, just like any other business that has something it knows is hugely valuable to a large number of people. But instead, they prefer to sell everyone's eyeballs to advertisers. How does this make sense?
Google used to run a program called Contributor which let you pay them the minimum amount you'd have to to opt out of ads (you basically just paid them and they used your money to automatically outbid everyone who wanted to advertise to you). I wish they brought this back because I really liked it. They changed it completely so it only worked with "participating sites" [0], which was basically nobody, then killed it altogether (but left the page up).
There's an easy solution to this: what economists call price discrimination. Basically, people who can afford to pay more, pay more, and people who can't afford to pay more, don't.
It looks like the Contributor program you describe could have been set up to do this.
Yes, I get that Google and Facebook and Twitter and friends have gotten people accustomed to having all these wonderful services that everyone loves to use somehow magically appear on the Internet for free. That doesn't mean it's actually free. It just means that the costs are hidden.
Which is all fine in and of itself: if everyone else wants to hand over their private data to be sold, sure, go ahead, do it. I don't even have a Twitter account, and while I have a Facebook account I almost never use it and have entered zero data beyond my name into its profile. I can't quite say the same about my Google account, since I do buy books and apps from Google Play, but it's as close as I can get it to zero data in its profile. So I at least have some way of limiting how much I am participating in the great selling of personal data.
However, I don't have a way of getting better service from Google for things that could be better services if those of us who want the better service were allowed to pay for it. That's one of the standard ways of doing price discrimination, and should be very familiar to anyone who has dealt with cloud services, or indeed anyone who has used an app with a freemium business model: service tiers. The lowest tier is the free one; the other tiers are progressively more expensive and provide more added functionality. But Google can't be bothered to do it for its hugely useful apps like Maps and search, and then they tell us how difficult it is to staff these hugely useful apps with enough engineering resources. It doesn't add up.
I'm going to say this as a user. Google Maps is fucking fantastic. The team responsible for it should be proud:
* Free
* Great data - almost always accurate
* Editable - I can contribute
Genuinely an amazing product. And all these people on the Internet saying it's shite. No fucking way. It's fantastic. If you ever listen to these people for even a second, go and listen for half that time to folks on the street. They love your shit.
I am with you on not being willing to pay anything for the service.
They are also complaining that someone wants to run a public utility and be the centralized point for information but also doesn't want to pay enough to make that public utility accurate.
Not saying that its even feasible to do so, but that's why we pool funds for utilities - we all use them and we all have an incentive to make them not shit.
What if it were not offered for free? What if you had to pay a subscription of, say, $10 a year? Would you pay for it then?
If your answer is yes, then it's not that you're not willing to pay anything for it; you are simply taking advantage of the fact that right now you don't have to. But the fact that you don't have to is a side effect of the ad-supported business model, which IMO is doing a lot of damage that could be avoided if only Google would take the simple step that businesses have taken since time immemorial, of charging its users directly for the services they use.
If your answer is no, then evidently this application is not as great and wonderful and useful as people are claiming it is, since it isn't even worth a $10/year subscription, i.e., about 1/10 the price of Netflix.
Google Maps is universal, dude. The fact that you can't even comprehend $10 being a lot of money is amazing. Truly truly amazing. But I must say I fully expected it.
The fact that you can't even comprehend that to anyone who is posting here on HN, $10 is not very likely to be a lot of money, is what I find truly amazing. Not to mention your blithe acceptance of something like Google Maps being "universal, dude", as though it were a law of physics that such complicated and useful applications will just appear for free, or that there couldn't possibly be any downsides to such a state of affairs.
"Almost always" when you have billions of data points means millions, or even tens of millions, of wrong data points. That doesn't seem great to me. It certainly won't seem great to all the people and businesses whose data is wrong and who have no way of getting it corrected. Which is exactly the point of the article this discussion is about.
> all these people on the Internet saying it's shite
We are saying no such thing. I agree that it is a hugely useful application. I just think it would be even more useful, not to mention less damaging to all the people and businesses that are hit by the "almost" above, if it had at least some of its users as paying customers instead of being solely driven by Google's ad-supported business model.