A long time ago, a high school diploma was rigorous enough that people actually failed. A significant number of people did not earn one. Now, I don't even know of a friend of a friend who has failed to earn one, even if they just kept on retaking the courses at relatively easy schools until they passed.
It isn't clear to me what holding a high school diploma indicates about a person anymore simply because nearly everyone gets one.
What does holding a high school diploma prove?