> Why not have a little positivity that AWS is finally restricting access to their technology beyond what is legally required?
Because it's not enough. "Please sir, may I have some more" is not how you address the weaponization of technology by a trillion dollar org.
Don't like the Big Tech corporate surveillance state? Write better laws regulating them. Don't like the people writing laws currently? Vote and run against them. Still not heard? There are yet more avenues for recourse.
The idea that technology is going to fix these problems holds no basis in reality.
My only point here is: Currently, people do not trust independent oversight (read: government). And there are probably a few good reasons. So, I don't see how saying "Amazon should only sell this technology with independent oversight" fixes anything as long as the trust problem isn't solved.
If you do truly hold the belief that governments are "the definition of independent", and that all governments act solely in the best interests of their own citizens...well, to borrow some words from Public Enemy: Can't do nuttin' for ya man.
We're literally talking about the government using facial recognition with no oversight and little public debate and no consent from the public, so you wouldn't have an excuse for coming out with this "government is all of us working together" lorem ipsum even if you were born 30 seconds before the article was posted and didn't know anything about the way that governments actually behave in practice.
You come so very close to getting it, in that you acknowledge that this isn't how governments work in reality, and then you're like "well neither is anything else though" as if that is somehow an argument for a strategy that you kinda-acknowledge cannot work.
And FWIW: I agree, it's fucked, it needs to stop, both in the public and private sector, and anyone that works on such tech should be shunned. But your assumptions are false to fact.
Arguably we need a much more principled, stronger stance on opposition to mass surveillance period. Companies that understand the ethical obligations should get out of it completely.
https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/5dm8bx/leaked-amazon-memo...
Treating their motives with anything but the utmost cynicism seems the rational move here.
What percent of AWS revenue is from Rekognition? Probably a rounding error.
Closing a profit generating business line is all more difficult than closing an unproven one. Props to folks at Amazon, this a change for the better.
I'm wary about their competitors though. Looks like an opportunity for Microsoft to monopolise the face recognition software market. Can't think of any market force to solve this, and regulation would probably leave a lot of room to game the system.