A voice of reason speaks of the tragedies in Japan.
bbc.co.uk
bbc.co.uk
The apocalyptic visions of destruction brought by the Japanese earthquake and subsequent tsunami have been largely replaced in the media this week by reports of the struggle to control radiation from the stricken Fukushima nuclear plant.
Japan hasn't lost any area. Unlike Chernobyl's reactors, which were still fissioning at the time of the disaster, Japan's were not stuffed full of burning graphite.
Some minutes after the earthquake, the tsunami physically hit Daiichi and Daini. (You haven't heard of Daini in about a week because we've reestablished control there.) It wiped out their diesel generators and external power lines, because both had tolerances in the five to six meter range for tsunamis and the actual wVe was nine to ten.
Things, incredibly, still didn't go to pot immediately. They worked on battery backup for a few hours, but couldn't get an emergency plan in operation in time without power. That's when things started to get bad, principally with overheating from waste heat causing radioactive steam/hydrogen explosions, which were the first cause of radioactivity spikes and have complicated all the disaster response since. (Though, perversely, the fact that Daiichi 3 had a steam/hydrogen explosion blow the roof off made the spent fuel pool accessible to water delivered without entering the building, without which getting a hose inside would have been a one-way trip.)
Thinking the radiation has future higher expected harm than the tsunami is pretty much solely a problem of cognitive biases.
Citation needed for this one, other than one coming from an industry-lobbyist like IAEA.
http://books.google.com/books?id=g34tNlYOB3AC&lpg=PA186&...
I can tell you that in the case of my country, Romania, the numbers are probably even higher because of a lot of mis-reporting (voluntary or not), or just plain stupidity from the doctors when it came to diagnosing (just fyi, we had close to 7,000 kids "accidentally" infected with HIV at at the end of the '80s).
> Because of his activities, he lost his job and got problems with the State Security Agency of Belarus, which threatened him with internment in a psychiatric asylum. Later, however, the Belarusian government tried to soften him proposing him to get back a job in a state institute, "at the condition that he would not work on Chernobyl anymore." He escaped two assassination attempts.[1]
> Nesterenko intervened immediately after news of the accident in the nuclear power plant started to spread. As an expert on the subject and with his experience as a fire fighter, he threw liquid nitrogen containers from a helicopter on the burning reactor core. To do this he had to move into the middle of radioactive smoke. Despite the heavy radioactive contamination of the area, Nesterenko survived. However, of the four passengers of his helicopter, three died from radioactive irradiation and contamination.[1]
There's nothing anybody can say to make Chernobyl not be a terrible disaster. But we can (and did) learn from it.