1) Because SEO is today was HTML was in 1995: A simple and basic concept that almost anyone can master, but is portrayed as some high-level mystery "language". I think most hackers get upset when simple ideas are over-hyped and blown out of proportion. In many ways "SEO" is nothing more than quality/standards-based site design and relevant and current content. Maybe something like AP English for the web: not mentally tasking, just a lot of rules to know
2) (Perhaps the bigger reason) Because SEO disrupts the natural food chain of the web. If someone is passionate, knowledgeable and committed to their site or the business underlying the site, they will tend to naturally rank high in SERPs. This would likely be because they put the time into making sure the layout is clean and orderly, the content is accurate and up to date, and the site is overall valuable. In exchange for this, users who are interested in whatever niche that site serves reward them by referencing other users to the site in blog posts, forums, etc. Now, you get someone with an inferior site who puts their effort in SEO and not The Site and wants to jump to the head of the line in a way that they didn't earn. Now users who are trying to find quality content or products in that category are sidetracked by this high-ranking but overall less valuable site that came up as results #1, #2, and #4 in their search for "widgetA". Most hackers despise this blatant manipulation of the servers and algorithms that are impartial and on a more level playing field will yield the correct results to a query. Maybe we don't like SEO because it exposes the flaws and frailties of our system :)
To answer your question: trying to make your site rank better is a good thing, especially if you do this by making user-centric improvements to the site and content. Trying to make your site rank higher than it naturally deserves to is equated to Spam.
http://www.google.com/support/webmasters/bin/answer.py?hl=en...
Many SEOs and other agencies and consultants provide useful services for website owners, including:
* Reviewing and providing recommendations on your site content or structure
* Technical advice on website development: for example, hosting, redirects, error pages, use of JavaScript
* Content development
* Managing online business development campaigns
* Keyword research
* SEO trainingCheckout some of the advanced techniques listed on http://www.bluehatseo.com/ and then reconsider your SEO plan.
If you want your site to rank better simply provide something people want and try to give good, fresh, content on a regular basis. This is perhaps the best way to achieve a good (organic) ranking.
Users you "earn" also tend to stay longer, be more active, more loyal, and will link to you and spread the word anyway, which is what you want.
With good users and traffic you will automatically get better rankings and have good monetisation options too, such as advertising/adwords, if you do not already charge for your service.
Lastly, have a blog as that is probably the best SEO tip most sites do not utilise.
It depends on what exactly do you do and don't do.
For example, if your site has poorer content or less usable service, but you used various tricks to rank higher as sites with better content or more usable service, then that's somewhat despicable, I'd say. You might have wasted other people time, because without your "SEO", they could have been served better by SE. I would not use the word evil, though.
But if you just provide sitemap or use the <title> tag correctly, that's ok.
Not according to Latest SEO Trick #29832 that you* read somewhere.
(* "you" not meaning you personally, of course)
Google and Yahoo can, and do change the rules of the game all the time by changing their algorithm, so just make sure you have your bases covered with the things that you cant get pinged for.
There's a lot to do, from the URL, to keyword frequency to use of header tags to if you should have a unique IP and how long your domain is registered for -- and that's before you even leave your own site. A brilliant hacker can write a useful, scalable app that has little to no internal SEO and get fewer visitors as a result.
Then there's all the little games people play to get links: begging for them, paying for them, press releases, "do follow" comments on blogs, and the dreaded DMOZ. It's a drain on a small company that probably just wants to build a better application.
1. Use semantic markup and SEO best practices
(http://www.seomoz.org/blog/the-web-developers-seo-cheat-sheet)
2. Email people and tell them to link to you
Grey hat: 1. Buy paid links without nofollow on forums.digitalpoint.com
(not detected by Google yet, but they'll figure it out eventually because the affordable links are all spam-like webpages
that exist only for the purpose of having pagerank and selling links. For more money, you can get better links from real sites, or you can hire an SEO that knows what he is doing. Ideally you only pay him for the links and you handle all other SEO yourself, because it isn't worth paying for.) 2. Write articles and upload them to free article databasesWe have to remember as hackers, startups, or computer/web literate people, we should be doing most of this ourselves, but for most people (SMEs or mom & pop with their website/ecommerce store) this will be foreign to them and hence the market for (good?) SEO practitioners.
Whereas bad SEO practice (using link-farms, link-baiting, paid-for directories) will certainly harm your site (Google penalize against sites that do this and there are many cases of sites paying for SEO only to see a early rise followed by a sharp fall later), good SEO at the basic level can significantly help.
Programming is nothing but learning a few keywords. Let me know if I am missing something ...
1. Use waterfall model and programming best practises. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waterfall_model
2. Mix for, while, def and class keywords in appropriate quantities.
Advanced programming methods:
1. Build some rectanges and lines called as UMLs.
2. Learn about some libraries and mix them with the for, if, def keywords.
Sorry to be so snarky, but what sites have you SEOd for?
(Oh and I am a programmer, BTW)
Email me if you want my list of web sites...
But like some people mentioned, there are a lot of SEO tips that people should be aware of, and quite a lot that programmers should be aware of if they're going to program a good site. Some simple programming choices in the beginning can make a big difference to your site's ranking, so if you're not aware of what those are, then you're not being a good programmer. Check out http://www.netconcepts.com/tag/case-studies