Related: Wikipedia's current events portal [1] acts like a user sourced news feed which is a pretty good representation of reality. I wonder if you could commercialize a similarly moderated aggregator.
Related: Wikipedia's current events portal [1] acts like a user sourced news feed which is a pretty good representation of reality. I wonder if you could commercialize a similarly moderated aggregator.
I watched a couple of amateur WW2 history videos on YouTube and almost immediately started getting suggestions for some very questionable alt right kinda stuff.
Again, if one believes serving users content which is exactly what they want to see if that is what users prefer is wrong, then only allowing people to see completely un-selection-biased content is even more right.
There's a need for longform journalism, synthesis of information, bias and persuasion. It's hard to consume just that without also consuming the daily noise.
Longer stories will look less engaging unless facebook also tracks how long you spend reading each site.
What? It's important that Facebook curates biased information and intentionally persuasive content for you because you're otherwise unwilling/unable to seek that out yourself?
I may have misread this entirely, but I'm pretty sure you can find RSS feeds for most news sources outside of AP/Reuters. Whatever content you'd prefer with any sort political or ideological slant you'd like is freely available outside of Facebook by definition.
If RSS isn't available for Breitbart or Daily Beast or KCNA or Patribotics or whatever, surely there must be an easy way to consume that outside of the Facebook platform?
On one hand, you can have a story that says "3 people cut their grass today" and on the other hand you can have a story that says "3 people cut their grass today, their reason for doing so, and why you should join them in grass cutting unity." The latter is much more important to a functioning democracy than the former.
The crucial part you missed is:
>It's hard to consume just that without also consuming the daily noise.
RSS is filled with noise. It's filled with stories that are stories because space needed to be filled, that capture your attention for the sake of capturing your attention, not to educate you on things you "need to know."
The whole point of something like Facebook's algorithm is to identify a signal from noise. It is very hard to consume the news without consuming noise, and that is an opportunity for Facebook to actually do something morally right (as opposed to agnostic) and identify what is important for people to learn. That by definition is going to involve a level of bias. Its going to involve them going against everything they believe in, NOT using engagement data to rank content, something I dont think their organization is really capable of.
Drudge tells you "heres what important to know for the day." Techmeme tells you "heres what important to know for the day." Wikipedia Current Events tells you "heres what important to know for the day." Reddit and Facebook tell you "heres what the most people with short attention spans clicked on today."
The world needs better aggregation of important stories.
Why can't news be chosen on engagement? That's what people want to read. Must Facebook control what news people are reading?
Wikipedia's current event portal may have a more even representation of what events are happening, but Wikipedia also has users that are interested in a wider range of topics. Most people mainly care about sports and politics. Scientific discoveries, economics, and international relations are simply not as interesting to as many people. Why shouldn't Facebook just have news based on engagement and a separate list with equal representation of events from many different topics?
Because what most people engage with can't be accurately described as "news".
>That's what people want to read. Must Facebook control what news people are reading?
Much more likely Facebook is trying to hide from the world just how vapid and dim most of its users are.
> Must Facebook control what news people are reading?
No, only what news they promote to their network. I don't care if FB manual curates the list or uses an algorithm, they're involved in the design and so they're making an editorial decision here.
They can optimize only for engagement with no curation, but they shouldn't. It shouldn't be done that way because people won't understand that this is the mechanism for content selection. They will think that because content shows up in a news section it has factual merit, and that the content being presented is an accurate representation of the current world context. If you only prioritize engagement, what you will create is a propaganda section masquerading as a news section because the most inflammatory, baseless, bullshit content is what draws the most engagement. That is in no one's best interest long term and it undermines the credibility of news media in general. If they want to create this, it should be labeled as entertainment, not news.
Is a propaganda section a propaganda section if it contains propaganda from both sides? I suppose, in that it is a section that contains propaganda, but the section itself does not serve as an unequal biasing agent for viewers, unless your issue with the engagement-based recommendation is that you believe it is biased in a certain direction.
That seems like quite the assumption to assume that people will think content has factual merit because it shows up in their news section. People should not be treated with kid gloves and herded in certain directions out of fear that we will harm ourselves. Facebook should clearly label news sections as "Selections Based on Engagement" and "Selections By Facebook Curators". People are capable of understaning that the selected news is biased.
It is based on what makes people the most upset. That’s what makes people stop what they were doing before, and click.
That’s what Facebook is built to do: elevate content that “stops the thumb”. This is a direct quote from a FB rep advising my employer on how to perform better on Facebook. Here’s another one: “don’t be reasonable, be extreme. You need to stand out.”
Imagine if you picked anything else that way. Only making friends with people who make you the most upset. Only eating foods that make you the most upset. Only dating people who make you the most upset. Is that a good life or bad life?