Should we charge the journalists who distributed Snowden's leaks as well?
This seems like making a distinction to draw a line between the two, but I am missing the explanation for why this distinction has moral import.
Should we charge the journalists who distributed Snowden's leaks as well?
This seems like making a distinction to draw a line between the two, but I am missing the explanation for why this distinction has moral import.
We don't need to, we know who their source was (Snowden). If Assange wants to claim he's a journalist, that's fine, but then he either needs to accept the consequences of protecting his sources, or out his sources.
> but I am missing the explanation for why this distinction has moral import.
It's a question of responsibility. When a journalist protects their sources, they accept responsibility for the consequences, and they they chose to reveal their source, they pass on the consequences to their source, but (usually) take a hit to their reputation as a journalist. Assange appears to not want to accept any consequences for his actions, nor pass them on be revealing his sources.
I also understand that no journalist has ever been successfully prosecuted, but no case has ever gone to the Supreme Court about it either.
My understanding about the Assange case in particular is that they are pursuing other crimes because they are more likely to stick and more likely to result in extradition. But that doesn't mean he's not guilty of other crimes.
I'm not a lawyer though, so if there is other information I'm missing, I'd definitely like to learn about it.
It seems that Wikileaks and the like do not neatly fit under previous classifications we may have. They certainly don't fit the legal ones, as those seem to mostly cut populations into free speech for citizens and foreign spies.
On a related note, off the top of my head I do recall that at least a few of the lawyers and journalists who were involved with Wikileaks, and Edward Snowden, were apparently advised to go into political exile. I think at least some of them did return last I heard.
Journalists are legally required to put their sources or they are on the hook?
I suggest you revisit the case history on this subject.
Can you point me at some links? I'm not a lawyer but my understanding is that shield laws are state by state, and there are no federal protections.