So there's one big factor that plays into all of this: for business travel, the company's paying. Employees don't really bear the cost, so the incentive is to choose the more convenient option. Parking etc. can all be expensed (not a big deal with Spothero, etc.). And companies usually have negotiated rates with rental car companies. So there's inertia.
I just checked my National invoice for my last LAX rental: the nominal daily rate for was $31/day, but with airport concession fees, tax, etc. it came out to $37/day (the car was a 2019 Dodge Challenger). I don't remember how much I paid for gas but gas is pretty cheap these days so it couldn't have been more than $40 (200 miles driven). So yes daily rate is higher, but not really double.
Would I pay $100-$200 for unlimited trips on rideshare? Not for business travel, no because like I said, for the non-urban geographies I work in, a rental car is just more convenient and the company's paying (plus my time costs money).
For personal trips? Well, Lyft does have a subscription program for commuters but I'm probably not the target demographic (I have my own car for groceries, but otherwise I walk everywhere or take the L). I also have a free Lyft Pink subscription through my credit card but that hasn't really increased my Lyft use.
I suspect during COVID the attractiveness of rideshare will actually decline -- I'm personally wary of getting into a confined space with someone else even with every precaution taken. But post-COVID, it's likely things will return to normal. Rideshare has been and will likely continue to be an important component of my urban transport mix. I just don't see it being dominant over all others.