Simply put, the school officials made a bet and lost.
Simply put, the school officials made a bet and lost.
If the school board pays for the construction of a new auditorium, and the new building is left half-finished by a bankrupt contractor, you would blame the contractor rather than the school board itself. This should be no different.
The school officials have a responsibility to the public, while the contractor does not.
You do realize what you're writing ?
Next time you'll be robbed by some entity, you'll sure remember that it's your fault, that you had to conduct due diligence.
They can hire independent experts to assess whether the job has been done correctly, the same way one would get a second opinion on work that has been done that's outside one's field of expertise. There are plenty of engineering firms that will inspect bridges, oil wells, and other infrastructure.
Alternatively, they could choose to not get in the oil business in the first place.
They're barely in the oil business, they've just renting out the land, some small space, the mineral rights to cover holes in their budgets.
If you're from Oklahoma, Texas, or another major oil-producing state, you have probably seen oil wells situated near schools, neighborhoods, or other sites that may present a hazard to young people. California is one of the largest oil producers in the country, so I'm not surprised that they have oil production in urban/suburban areas. Weird? Maybe. Unhealthy? Probably.
Drilling at the site precedes the establishment of the school in 1927, as there is a large oil field beneath Beverly Hills into which around 100 wells have been drilled from four clusters, one of which is the school's property. That oil field was discovered in 1900. A single year's production at the school used to produce millions of dollars' worth of oil (not including natural gas).
So, at some point administrators in the district weighed the pros and cons and said, "ok we'll tap into that revenue source." Whether that was a weird or not-weird decision, I think it was reasonable to assume that the well operators would follow lawful practices and would not be able to duck the cost of plugging wells at the end of their life. Venoco certainly made a lot of money from its decades of operating those wells.
California backed the school district in this dispute. The California State Lands Commission went after Venoco for the money, but a federal judge in Delaware affirmed the bankruptcy court ruling and denied California's claim.
I think this situation says way more about bankruptcy law and bonding requirements for oil and nat gas wells, than it says about well placement. This is not an isolated problem. As bankrupt producers like Whiting and Chesapeake are sure to be followed by other firms in the coming months, we are going to see more examples of the same.
Bonding requirements should reflect the real cost of plugging wells, and creditors of bankrupt petroleum companies should not be permitted to recoup assets before those assets are used to cover the cost of mitigating environmental hazards.
That principle holds whether the well is on a school district's property, on private property nearby, or out in the middle of nowhere.
Should we hold school districts more liable than other landowners for the costs of plugging wells? Or should a licensed well operator be expected to set aside money for plugging the wells that it operates?
nothing in this article makes sense if you try to imagine the people involved in any of those situations. It's not like those things happened by themselves.
The responsibility would legally have rested with the well operator, but the well operator went bankrupt.
If you read the article, you will see that abandoned wells often end up in limbo between the bankrupt operator and its creditors. Meanwhile, the landowner is facing the negative externalities of the well (seepage, gas leaks, etc), and often has no choice but to pay to resolve the problems caused by the well being poorly terminated. There are supposed to be bonds in place to pay for these processes, but in practice those bonds only cover a fraction of the cost.
- Not allowed the development, and avoided the risks.
- Insured against the risks.
- Sold the land, along with all the risks.
They did none of these, and effectively self-insured; now they expect pity, which they do not deserve.
Had the operator not filed for bankruptcy, it would likely have been responsible for its own failure to appropriately manage the wells.
Had the state or federal government established adequate bonding practices to pay for the plugging of old and unproductive wells such as these, the burden of plugging these particular wells would have been lessened.
The school officials were operating under current conditions, and have no real excuse that I know of.
So what you are saying essentially is the school board/county should file bankruptcy so taxpayers are stuck with the liability...then we can extend your argument to the taxpayers for their failure to avoid the risks of funding/operating schools and insuring against them.
Do you feel that way about all the workers/businesses Trumps bankrupt businesses failed to pay by seeking bankruptcy protections?
This is only half true. The responsibility is delegated to the operator by the land owner, but it is ultimately the land owner's liability. Consider if the land owner was leasing the rights to the operator and then decided to change the lease agreement in a way that made the operator insolvent. If it were the way you describe the operator would be hostage of the landowner. Allowing the liability to pass upstream to the property owner makes complete sense.
Economic benefit derived only as a landowner or from a royalty interest is generally not sufficient to establish liability for plugging a well. If the operator were solvent, it would have had to pay.
Also, Venoco's bankruptcy wasn't caused by this lease agreement.