There's nothing easier to do than for China to point to this policy and say America is sending troops to an internal conflict in China.
There's nothing easier to do than for China to point to this policy and say America is sending troops to an internal conflict in China.
It is an executive communiqué [1]. There is no treaty. "One China" is based on a statement of convenience. It could literally be reversed with a tweet.
What isn't just buttered-up memos are the Taiwan Relations Act [2] and Taiwan Travel Act [3]. Unlike the joint communiqué, these are U.S. law.
Lots of Americans live in Taiwan. Taiwan hosts scores of American-made military assets defending it from Beijing. And high-ranking Americans are almost constantly in Taiwan. If Beijing attacked Taiwan, these would be among the collateral damage.
> say America is sending troops to an internal conflict in China
Everyone says everything when war breaks out. If Beijing blew up a bunch of Taiwanese assets, taking out a handful of Americans in the process, I see no obstacle to strong political support in America to intervene.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Communiqué
> treating Taiwan as a sub-sovereign foreign state equivalent
Also nothing from [2] or [3] guarantees American military intervention. Essentially, [2] and [3] solidified the status of Taiwan as 'not a full sovereign'.
This was never the goalpost. The original comment contrasted the legal flimsiness of the joint communiqué with the Acts underlying the U.S.-Taiwan relationship.
> solidified the status of Taiwan as 'not a full sovereign'
Not really. The Acts give deference to the executive branch.
Usually, the U.S. can't sell fighter jets to non-sovereign customers. The Acts created exceptions for Taiwan, so the President could continue paying lip service to Beijing while treating Taiwan like a sovereign nation.
I'm not saying these examples were right or just, I'm just saying I think a statement like that from China would have zero impact on the U.S. defending Taiwan.
If you think Vietnam War was bad, try a war in China.
If China were losing badly enough, they'd throw the nuclear card on the table. It presents a difficult scenario overall, as China can always draw a stalemate by using that whenever convenient: stop or I'll use nukes; it's the ultimate homefield advantage. If you're winning away from your home turf, and you're under threat of being nuked, your population will never support pressing forward (it would never be worth it, gain a bit of foreign land temporarily and lose your cities).
So, no, this issue is not resolved, regardless of whoever says it is.
I'd say the existence of the de facto recognition is more significant than the lack of de jure recognition. There's no real central authority in international relations, so the official statements and pieces of paper are pretty meaningless without the de facto actions of the countries in question back them up.
> There's nothing easier to do than for China to point to this policy and say America is sending troops to an internal conflict in China.
It's easy for the PRC to say whatever it likes, who else cares is a different matter.