Just because their own rules say 'everybody owes us money' doesn't mean that it's legal.
If I build a high end hotel and the fee is $10,000 a night to stay there, you can’t apply to the Supreme Court to have your bill reduced. It’s my hotel and I can set the price to whatever I damn well please because it’s a free market.
If the hotel opened a food court and treated the vendors like this, it might be an apt analogy.
What are they doing with the proprietary data from other marketplace competitors?
That's literally an Apple to Oranges comparison. Market share is not a requirement for illegality under the Sherman Act, as an example.
It might not be specifically anti-trust violation, but if Ford behaved the same as Apple there would be 1-2 cars to pick from world wide!
This isn't anti-trust.
- United States v. Griffith, 334 U.S. 100 (1948)
There have been a number of bench decisions based on barriers to entry and market entrenchment to prohibit this sort of behavior by oligopolies, even if the Sherman act didn't specifically mention them.
No? Looks a lot like a monopoly, in antitrust terms, then.
What are effectively independent, descriptively similar, side-by-side markets that people don't move between in response to pricing changes aren't the same market for antitrust purpose, even if conventional media coverage labels them the same market and talks about marketshare in the combined market.